Re:Doug Lemov believes great teachers are made, not born
by caminante on Friday March 13, 2015 @08:23PM
(#9200946)
I disagree. Think about the implications of using an app v. pen + paper. I assume the device would need to remain unlocked, have notifications turned off (e.g. email), and the screen isn't currently synched with a projector among other assumptions. Are these reasonable? If so, can you elaborate on what you're envisioning for both scenarios (app v. pen)?
Re:Doug Lemov believes great teachers are made, not born
by taeric on Friday March 13, 2015 @08:47PM
(#9201060)
In either case, the instructor would need training to do the actions discretely. Waiting for a teacher to go jot down any notes is annoying.
Re:Doug Lemov believes great teachers are made, not born
by caminante on Friday March 13, 2015 @09:00PM
(#9201096)
A teacher would need training to explain class participation and write a checkmark? Students are too clever to not notice. There's nothing to hide.
Re:Doug Lemov believes great teachers are made, not born
by taeric on Friday March 13, 2015 @10:18PM
(#9201300)
Yes, a teacher would need training for this. Did you read the article linked? One of the initial points was praise for the teacher addressing a kids behavior without the rest of the class noticing. This isn't something that is just natural. It is a skill that is built. Some people have just been building it for so long that it seems natural
Re:Doug Lemov believes great teachers are made, not born
by caminante on Saturday March 14, 2015 @12:42AM
(#9201578)
Huh?
This sub-thread isn't about ways to correct student behavior (Doug Lemov article). We're talking about the NARST article, which explicitly lists a process where you call on students, using a roster. There's nothing discreet about that.
How is using a phone/tablet for this purpose any more distracting from the lecture than using a paper + writing instrument + writing? A mobile device isn't going to get in the way than keeping an attendance sheet on a desk/podium/clipboard and using that.