News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US School Kids Are Doing Better Than Ever – But You Never... by Alex3917 on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @02:13PM (#920007)
Wow, this has to be just about the most blatant propaganda piece I've ever read. They somehow managed to avoid citing a single relevant fact or statistic, and yet claim that there is 'evidence' that our school system is largely succeeding. Reading this truly makes me feel like I'm from another planet or something.

edit: Let me just preempt this whole discussion by saying that anyone who claims that more people going through the system means that the system is of high quality is being incredibly intellectually dishonest.

Re:US School Kids Are Doing Better Than Ever – But You Never... by scott_s on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @03:28PM (#920200)
There is a correlation between people going through the system and people actually getting an education. If the opposite were true - less people were going through the system - I'd be very worried.

The problem with "high quality" is that I don't know how to measure it. If we can't measure it, then it's difficult to have a meaningful discussion about whether one thing is better than the other. That is, we're restricted to a purely qualitative discussion that's not based on evidence. Graduation and enrollment statistics don't measure quality, but I think they are a coarse indicator of where we are.