News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Julian Assange case: Sweden offers to question him in UK by ptaipale on Friday March 13, 2015 @07:12AM (#9196535)
Exactly. Looking at the whole business from a Nordic perspective, the idea of this process being some kind of a plot to extradite Assange to be tortured by the Americans is just silly. Britain is the poodle in U.S.'s pocket, not Sweden.

A more rational perspective to the situation can be seen from the point of view of rape statistics. They are an indication of how seriously countries take accusations of sexual molestation. The rate of police-recorded rape offenses is

- US: 27.3

- UK: 28.8

- Sweden: 63.5

Are there really more than twice as many rapes per capita in Sweden than there are in UK or US? Of course not, if you use the same definition for rape. The issue is that Sweden records things differently. I'm quite convinced that if we're looking at what actually happens, Sweden has less rape then UK or US, but Sweden records them with a much lower threshold for what constitutes a "rape" so that the statistics looks different.

Re:Julian Assange case: Sweden offers to question him in UK by vidarh on Friday March 13, 2015 @07:58AM (#9196686)
> Britain is the poodle in U.S.'s pocket, not Sweden.

Sweden has a history of actively handing asylum seekers to the CIA for illegal rendition without even the knowledge of any courts.

The UK doesn't to my knowledge have a history of handing over people without proper extradition proceedings, some that have dragged out in the court system for years.

Re:Julian Assange case: Sweden offers to question him in UK by xorcist on Friday March 13, 2015 @03:00PM (#9199201)
That's a simplification that's so far stretched it doesn't make sense.

The UK has also extradited people under terrorist laws, just like the Swedish case you keep referring to. Sweden also has a history of protecting deserters from the US army, from the Vietnam era onwards.

But neither of this matters, because the whole theory doesn't make sense. If Assange was sent to Sweden for questioning, the very same international agreements that got him sent there would only allow him to be sent back to the UK, nowhere else.

Re:Julian Assange case: Sweden offers to question him in UK by rmc on Saturday March 14, 2015 @09:07AM (#9202494)
The UK has a history of imprisoning people without trail, and suspending trail by jury within British courts in Northern Ireland. They don't need to hand them over to anywhere.
Re:Julian Assange case: Sweden offers to question him in UK by ptaipale on Friday March 13, 2015 @08:00AM (#9196691)
In this case the idea that this could happen without knowledge of any courts is rather absurd because the whole point was to bring Assange to a court.
Re:Julian Assange case: Sweden offers to question him in UK by vidarh on Friday March 13, 2015 @08:11AM (#9196724)
The point was that no extradition request was made, or reviewed by any court, and that the renditions were done in flagrant violation of international law, and directly led to the torture of at least two political asylum seekers.

Not only that, but the rendition flights with complicity of Swedish staff continued for years after they were initially uncovered and condemned and the government promised they would end.

Re:Julian Assange case: Sweden offers to question him in UK by jamespo on Friday March 13, 2015 @08:26AM (#9196760)
You'd have thought he considered that before raping someone there
Re:Julian Assange case: Sweden offers to question him in UK by balabaster on Friday March 13, 2015 @09:49AM (#9197044)
Not that I'm condoning his behaviour, but unless I'm missing a piece of the puzzle that I'm not understanding: Last I checked, anywhere outside of Sweden, having sex with a partner who appeared to be willing (until after the fact) is not rape. If that's the case, how do people not get charged with rape all the time?

Girl gets drunk, wakes up the morning after, looks over and would rather chew her own arm off than wake him up before escaping...

This kind of scenario has played out in countless movies and every university dorm since the beginning of time. Usually it's the guy who gets drunk and tries to escape, but the plot is the same.

So he woke her up with sex... something many millions of partners the world over have done countless times... and enjoyed. She appeared willing, consensual, into it - at least that's how it allegedly looked at the time, and then she cries foul after the fact...

Sounds an awful lot like she had sex with this guy, then she was jealous about him having sex with another girl, they both found out he was double dipping (as it were), were pissed that they weren't the center of his attention and thus decided to have him slapped with a rape charge.

Of course, that's just what one can glean from the various hyperbolic media reports. I'm quite sure it's more nuanced than that. But even with the hyperbole, that doesn't sound like rape, that sounds like a revenge tactic for jealousy. The fact that this could also play favour for a U.S. rendition really just compounds how suspicious this whole situation sounds.

If you were in the shoes of Assange, with 2 girls throwing themselves at you for sex (which is how it comes across in the media) and then in the midst of you leaking the largest trove of politically embarrassing documents that have ever been leaked, having them come forward with allegations of rape, in a country that until you start digging you had no idea they have a history of conspiracy to perform illegal rendition to the U.S...

It seems to me that the worst thing that happened here was poor judgment. If you have sex with two people at the same time and get busted, it's not unusual for them both to be pissed that they're not the only one... and I hate to say it, but people in that situation tend to do irrational things such as you might hear about in songs written by Carrie Underwood https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WaSy8yy-mr8 or worse... abuse the legal system for revenge.

Re:Julian Assange case: Sweden offers to question him in UK by chimeracoder on Friday March 13, 2015 @10:10AM (#9197154)
Putting aside the details of Assange's case for a moment:

> Not that I'm condoning his behaviour, but unless I'm missing a piece of the puzzle that I'm not understanding: Last I checked, anywhere outside of Sweden, having sex with a partner who appeared to be willing (until after the fact) is not rape. If that's the case, how do people not get charged with rape all the time?

That's actually not true at all - there are a number of situations in which a person can be legally incapable of consent. In various jurisdictions this can include someone who is too intoxicated, someone who is under the age of consent, someone who is a ward of the state (e.g. prisoners are legally unable to consent to sex), someone who is emotionally pressured or coerced, etc.

Rape convictions are very hard to secure for a number of reasons (the biggest one being that most victims don't pursue charges[0]), but that shouldn't confuse what is and isn't rape under the law.

> This kind of scenario has played out in countless movies and every university dorm since the beginning of time. Usually it's the guy who gets drunk and tries to escape, but the plot is the same.

Yes, and this is what is often referred to with the statement "rape culture" (which is often misunderstood and dismissed). There are a lot of things that are commonplace in movies that would be considered sexual assault in real life.

[0] Even if you were 100% sure that you could get a conviction, it's an incredibly exhausting, taxing and humiliating process for the victim, so most ultimately choose not to risk their mental health in the process.

Re:Julian Assange case: Sweden offers to question him in UK by balabaster on Friday March 13, 2015 @11:27AM (#9197611)
What I'm saying is that this is applying a "rape culture" label to something that I'm not really sure should be considered rape culture. I can point you in the direction of countless men and women that have had drunk sex and enjoyed it and gone back for more... many of whom proclaim the joys of morning sex and being woken up that way. How do you differentiate that from someone who is only having sex with you because they're drunk and waking up the next morning and regretting it? They're surely equally as likely to wake up the next morning, think they've scored and go back for second helpings... There is a morally fine line for sure... but I think "legally incapacitated" is reaching. She wasn't drugged to the point that she wasn't able to make decisions. Arguably she was drugged (by her own alcohol consumption) enough to make shitty decisions (perhaps). Lord knows we've all done that to ourselves at some point or another. But being drunk and making shitty decisions comes in the realm of don't drink and drive. It's not illegal for someone to get in the car with you while you're drunk at the wheel. Stupid, for sure, but if they get behind the wheel drunk and you get in the passenger seat equally drunk and they get in an accident and kill someone, are you an accessory to that crime? If they kill themselves because you let them get behind the wheel is that your fault? They made the shitty decision, you let them. Sure you'll probably feel terrible for letting that happen, their family might blame you for not keeping them out of trouble, but legally...? At what point does being drunk excuse you? How much alcohol do you have to consume? Did she initiate? Did he? Was he that drunk too? Does that matter? Can any of it be proven either way? In a court of law, being drunk doesn't legally excuse you from the ability to make decisions... which is why when you drink and drive, they're still legally able to charge you with "Causing death by careless driving when under the influence of drink." (in the UK) and "Driving While Intoxicated" or "Driving Under the Influence of Alcohol" in North America. If you are legally culpable for decisions contributing to a crime when under the influence of alcohol, then you cannot claim that someone is legally incapacitated from making decisions regarding sex when they consent to do so. You can have it one way or the other, but not both. If they're legally incapacitated from making decisions about their sex life, then surely they're legally incapacitated from making the decision to drink and drive, and thus are not legally responsible. Where does legal culpability draw the line?
Re:Julian Assange case: Sweden offers to question him in UK by toothbrush on Friday March 13, 2015 @02:03PM (#9198681)
> Arguably she was drugged (by her own alcohol consumption) enough to make shitty decisions ... being drunk and making shitty decisions comes in the realm of don't drink and drive...

This comparison is wrong to the point of being offensive. It's classic victim blaming. You're drunk, get raped? Your fault! "Being raped" and "driving a dangerous piece of equipment" seem very obviously different in terms of who is the victim and who the perpetrator.

Re:Julian Assange case: Sweden offers to question him in UK by balabaster on Friday March 13, 2015 @02:59PM (#9199184)
That's not at all what I'm saying. You're twisting my words to fit your own agenda...

What I'm saying is they were drunk and horny and wanted sex - both parties, consensual (from the way the media portrayed it.) Not rape. It wasn't until after the fact that she backtracked and changed her mind and decided that she retroactively didn't want sex after all and cried rape.

That's like me going back to a partner and saying, yeah, I know we had sex last night, but I'm regretting it now because I heard you had sex with my room mate, so I'm going to report you for rape. Which is exactly how it was portrayed.

Making a shitty decision to have sex with someone while under the influence of alcohol is entirely different than getting shit-face drunk (or drugged) and getting raped. These are two entirely different scenarios. The first is what I'm getting at - bad decision to have (consensual) sex, regretting it after the fact; the second is what you're getting at - getting too drunk to be in charge of your own destiny and unable to fend yourself off from someone you don't want sex with - this is rape and is inexcusable. In the scenario you're presenting, I'm entirely in agreement with you, but that's not the scenario as I perceived it, nor as I presented it. As the media presented it, I didn't see any real victim. I saw someone that played the victim card only as a result of coercion. The way her testimony was portrayed, I'm not even convinced that she felt she was a victim, she was a willing participant and only seemed to be going along with the rape allegation as part of some outside coercion or pressure. I genuinely read it like she had some affection for him and that she was sexually into him.

My point regarding the getting drunk and driving a dangerous piece of equipment is about legal culpability with regards to the ability to make decisions while under the influence of alcohol - not victim blaming. It's not about the indirect consequences of her decisions. It's about making a decision to participate in sex while under the influence of alcohol. In the legal sense this is no different than making a decision to drive a vehicle while under the influence of alcohol. If you're legally considered to have the mental capacity to make decisions in one scenario, you're legally considered to have the mental capacity to make decisions in the other.

If someone decides to have sex with someone while under the influence of alcohol, they can't use the legal excuse they were drunk. In exactly the same way as you can't get into a car accident and claim legal immunity because you were were drunk. In other words, you cannot be deemed legally able to make a decision in one scenario but not the other because you're drunk.

If it was rape and indeed it was non-consensual on her part, then her being drunk is irrelevant, just as it would be irrelevant what she was wearing. Rape is rape. But this was not portrayed as rape.

Re:Julian Assange case: Sweden offers to question him in UK by rmc on Saturday March 14, 2015 @09:14AM (#9202512)
One of the cases concerns someone who was asleep. What next? "Don't fall asleep"?
Re:Julian Assange case: Sweden offers to question him in UK by rmc on Saturday March 14, 2015 @09:11AM (#9202504)
You can only be extradited from one country to another if it's a crime in both countries. The UK High & Supreme Court looked at the charge(s), and concluded that if he did what was alledged in the UK, it would be a crime in the UK.

One of the 4 things he's wanted for is sex with someone who's asleep. That's rape in the UK. In fact "It's only a crime in the Sweden" would have been a perfect way to legally defeat the extradition request. His lawyers tried it. It didn't work.

Re:Julian Assange case: Sweden offers to question him in UK by icebraining on Friday March 13, 2015 @10:09AM (#9197150)
No mention of the condom? Seems like an important bit to me.
Re:Julian Assange case: Sweden offers to question him in UK by balabaster on Friday March 13, 2015 @11:32AM (#9197645)
Am I mistaken in recalling that this information was added to the story after the fact? Like it was an afterthought thrown in to try and give weight to an accusation that wasn't going to stick in the first instance?

I will admit that without going back and digging through the all original news stories again that my memory could be misleading me here... but I recall at the time that everything about this charge seemed sketchy to the point of suspicious.

Re:Julian Assange case: Sweden offers to question him in UK by vidarh on Friday March 13, 2015 @11:53AM (#9197784)
Last I checked he hasn't been convicted of anything, and the original prosecutor claimed there was no case.

Maybe he did, but neither you nor I know what actually happened. Unless you're Assange or one of the women.

Re:Julian Assange case: Sweden offers to question him in UK by lione on Friday March 13, 2015 @09:00AM (#9196874)
Allegedly
Re:Julian Assange case: Sweden offers to question him in UK by peterfirefly on Friday March 13, 2015 @12:42PM (#9198093)
Given the population change going on in Sweden, that's actually quite likely. A factor of 2 might be too small.
Re:Julian Assange case: Sweden offers to question him in UK by danabramov on Friday March 13, 2015 @07:56AM (#9196680)
... or maybe it's under-reported in UK or US?