News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gigaom Closes Down by brownbat on Monday March 09, 2015 @11:13PM (#9175787)
So here's a pesky theory that pops into my mind every time I hear a story like this. I really hope everyone will say it's crazy, though, because the consequences are pretty dire.

Advertising is good at selling some products, but advertisers are spectacular at selling advertising. So we've had almost a century-long bubble in bullshit.

The best way you outsell other advertisers, masters of bullshit themselves, all spinning how effective their ad is, is by selling metrics alongside your advertising. Metrics are the anti-bullshit. Well, almost...

You want something that looks like "actual sales caused." You want to tell a guy, "pay me $10 per ad, and I will generate 10 sales, each giving you $2 profit you wouldn't have otherwise made. We'll split the winnings."

You want to claim metrics for sales caused, but you don't really want those exact numbers, you kind of want something that looks hard that you can spin. Something loosely correlated with "actual sales caused" where your art of bullshitting can get slightly better returns than the exact numbers would get. Play to your strengths, right?

So magazines come along with subscription numbers, and that's great sauce. Then television comes along with the Nielsen family and, ok, actually Nielsen starts way back with radio in the 1920s, but same idea. Radio/television advertising reaches the most people and every company starts to pay a premium.

Advertisers have the whole industry sliced, diced, catalogued and formulated. Superbowl is the premium end, free weeklies are the bottom of the barrel. Everybody has a place, but everyone's using the same game to guess at eyeballs, to guess at actual sales caused.

Suddenly, though, there's this new game on the internet. Not a lot of eyeballs at first, so it starts in free weekly category. Suddenly though, Google (and maybe some other companies) can tell you how many ads are actually getting action rather than just eyeballs.

It's a metric like we've never seen before, it's the killer metric. Sure, you could get this from surveys, or test markets, but this is like measuring everyone who sees the ad. It's pretty cool.

But remember, metrics this accurate are dangerous, it shows when advertising doesn't work too.

And a lot of advertising is spin, a lot of it isn't all that great, because advertisers are better at selling ads than they are at selling your product.

I hope someone tells me this is all nonsense, though, because if it's true, then Internet advertising is both absorbing the advertising industry then destroying it.

That'd be sad. I mean, sure, it's showing us which of our emperors are already naked. But it might mean the constant death of random content sites like this.

Re:Gigaom Closes Down by anigbrowl on Monday March 09, 2015 @11:48PM (#9175898)
Advertising is good at selling some products, but advertisers are spectacular at selling advertising. So we've had almost a century-long bubble in bullshit.

This should be inscribed in 50-foot tall letters of fire hanging in the air above Silicon Valley.

Re:Gigaom Closes Down by Scoundreller on Tuesday March 10, 2015 @12:14AM (#9175988)
I agree. I think the demise of newspapers is largely from those buying advertising finally having hard and credible evidence that they were overpaying for a few centuries.

Advertising wasn't (and isn't) valueless, but the benefits were overextolled.

Re:Gigaom Closes Down by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday March 10, 2015 @03:43AM (#9176536)
> I agree. I think the demise of newspapers is largely from those buying advertising finally having hard and credible evidence that they were overpaying for a few centuries.

There is something else at work here though. It could be that people were overpaying for advertising, but it doesn't cost a lot more for a print ad than it would cost to have the ad printed and mailed to the same number of people who subscribe to the newspaper. The newspaper makes money because they put your ad in the newspaper they were already going to print and deliver and then they get to stick your ad money in their pocket. It's a nice deal for them.

But the internet equivalent of direct mail is spam. Or mailing lists to be more charitable. In ether case there is no printing and delivery cost. And the advertiser will now also have their own website which anyone can go to and view their products at trivial expense to the advertiser.

So sellers of advertising are no longer providing printing and delivery services or access to finite broadcast airtime. The equivalents of those things are no longer scarce or expensive.

The only thing they're selling is the ability to put your ad in front of customers who otherwise might not see it. Which might still be valuable if they had some kind of exclusivity in providing that, but they don't. Eyeballs aren't scarce either. Everybody visits many websites every day. The advertiser can get their ad in front of the customer by putting it on any subset of those websites, which then have to compete with each other for the advertiser's money.

So the price of advertising goes down. Somewhat fortunately for the likes of Google, then the Jevons paradox kicks in and people realize that if advertising becomes cheaper then it's profitable to buy more of it. So companies aren't spending less money on advertising.

But there are still many times more people selling it. And if companies spend twice as much on advertising but there are twenty times as many websites offering ad space, at the end of the day they each end up with ~10% of what they used to.

Re:Gigaom Closes Down by 001sky on Monday March 09, 2015 @11:32PM (#9175849)
There's a lot of interesing stuff in this comment. But it seems to conflate lead-gen with advertising. There are lots of reasons to advertise that don't relate to the sales funnel.

The second issue is alot of internet advertising is bullshit, including the metrics. Now, some things are good--actual-purchase links are decent data, but again that's really lead-gen not advertising.

If your lead already wants to buy your product, its too late for advertsing and you're really more into a different game. Nobody looks at an ad in the superbowl and the runs out and buy something 12 minutes later. The fact your narrative doesn't apply to that case is more a sign that something is missing in it, not that superbowl ads are mis-priced per se.

Re:Gigaom Closes Down by sbenario on Monday March 09, 2015 @11:49PM (#9175906)
The metrics are often broken. Think about how you measure it...

Ideally, you want to pay the ad platform for sending you a user who will buy your product. So you say something like: "I'll pay you X for every user you send me who buys something".

Great, right?

Except now the ad can simply optimize for users who were GOING to buy your product anyway. So now you've spent money getting users who would have been there anyway.

What you really want is to pay for users "Who buy my product, but would NOT have bought it without the presence of the ad". And that's a much harder thing to measure.

Re:Gigaom Closes Down by ghshephard on Tuesday March 10, 2015 @12:08AM (#9175968)
"Ideally, you want to pay the ad platform for sending you a user who will buy your product."

Brand advertising is built around the concept of "When a person is making a buying decision, I want them to buy my product."

We know it works, because when you stop doing brand advertising for things like Toilet Paper, Detergent, Toothpaste, Deoderant, etc... sales go down. And when you start the advertising again, sales go up.

Re:Gigaom Closes Down by mjevans on Tuesday March 10, 2015 @04:39AM (#9176667)
Don't people just sample the market to find out a brand that is to their tastes (performs as desired) and then keep buying it while the price is still of value?
Re:Gigaom Closes Down by ghshephard on Tuesday March 10, 2015 @06:20AM (#9176934)
There are a lot of theories, but, the one thing that has been consistent for at least the last 60 years, is that if you have a consumer Brand of something, say "Tide Detergent" - and you stop all your brand advertising in a certain region, sales go down in that region, and when you start advertising again, sales go back up.

Price, Value, Placement, and, obviously, competition are all conflating factors as well - but the underlying response to advertising has been pretty consistent.

Re:Gigaom Closes Down by mkr-hn on Tuesday March 10, 2015 @09:36AM (#9177612)
I've always wondered what the marketing campaigns look like for the 100 different brandings of the same product at the grocery store. Do Toothpaste A and Toothpaste Z340 target completely different demographics, or are they going for the same eyeballs with their ads?
Re:Gigaom Closes Down by muyuu on Tuesday March 10, 2015 @07:01AM (#9177051)
>Suddenly, though, there's this new game on the internet. Not a lot of eyeballs at first, so it starts in free weekly category. Suddenly though, Google (and maybe some other companies) can tell you how many ads are actually getting action rather than just eyeballs. >It's a metric like we've never seen before, it's the killer metric. Sure, you could get this from surveys, or test markets, but this is like measuring everyone who sees the ad. It's pretty cool. >But remember, metrics this accurate are dangerous, it shows when advertising doesn't work too.

I suspect that metric is nowhere as accurate as most people believe it to be. But I agree with the spirit of this message: a lot of the BS is getting exposed.

Re:Gigaom Closes Down by Pyxl101 on Tuesday March 10, 2015 @12:21AM (#9176005)
Interesting comment! Not entirely sure how relevant or accurate this is, but I thought I would point out that in Feb 2014, Om Malik from Gigaom wrote:

> In 2008, our company decided that we would not pray at the altar of pageviews and advertising metrics that do nothing but devalue our readers’ time and attention. Instead, we opted to take the road less traveled — subscription revenues.

https://gigaom.com/2014/02/20/now-that-gigaom-is-all-grown-u...

The post described their pivot into another line of business. (I'm not sure how much Gigaom relied on subscription revenue vs. advertising.)

Re:Gigaom Closes Down by hackuser on Tuesday March 10, 2015 @12:28AM (#9176022)
That has long been understood. An old saying from the days of print and TV/radio ads: Half of all advertising is wasted, but nobody knows which half.
Re:Gigaom Closes Down by mjevans on Tuesday March 10, 2015 @04:35AM (#9176651)
That seems optimistic.

I'm in the category where I don't need ads, I need timely and well categorized (machine sortable; accurate) results for product requests that I have when I discern a need.

I don't fell bad at all about running an adblocker because I would never have clicked on the ad to begin with (it also saves bandwidth and eyebleach); unobtrusive well placed and related text ads /might/ remind me of a need I had been meaning to fill.

Re:Gigaom Closes Down by osi on Tuesday March 10, 2015 @09:06AM (#9177484)
http://intellectual-thoughts.com/Alan%20Moore%20Quote.htm

There is some confusion as to what magic actually is. I think this can be cleared up if you just look at the very earliest descriptions of magic. Magic in its earliest form is often referred to as “the art”. I believe this is completely literal. I believe that magic is art and that art, whether it be writing, music, sculpture, or any other form is literally magic. Art is, like magic, the science of manipulating symbols, words, or images, to achieve changes in consciousness. The very language about magic seems to be talking as much about writing or art as it is about supernatural events. A grimmoir for example, the book of spells is simply a fancy way of saying grammar. Indeed, to cast a spell, is simply to spell, to manipulate words, to change people's consciousness. And I believe that this is why an artist or writer is the closest thing in the contemporary world that you are likely to see to a Shaman.

I believe that all culture must have arisen from cult. Originally, all of the faucets of our culture, whether they be in the arts or sciences were the province of the Shaman. The fact that in present times, this magical power has degenerated to the level of cheap entertainment and manipulation, is, I think a tragedy. At the moment the people who are using Shamanism and magic to shape our culture are advertisers. Rather than try to wake people up, their Shamanism is used as an opiate to tranquilize people, to make people more manipulable. Their magic box of television, and by their magic words, their jingles can cause everyone in the country to be thinking the same words and have the same banal thoughts all at exactly the same moment.

In all of magic there is an incredibly large linguistic component. The Bardic tradition of magic would place a bard as being much higher and more fearsome than a magician. A magician might curse you. That might make your hands lay funny or you might have a child born with a club foot. If a Bard were to place not a curse upon you, but a satire, then that could destroy you. If it was a clever satire, it might not just destroy you in the eyes of your associates; it would destroy you in the eyes of your family. It would destroy you in your own eyes. And if it was a finely worded and clever satire that might survive and be remembered for decades, even centuries. Then years after you were dead people still might be reading it and laughing at you and your wretchedness and your absurdity. Writers and people who had command of words were respected and feared as people who manipulated magic. In latter times I think that artists and writers have allowed themselves to be sold down the river. They have accepted the prevailing belief that art and writing are merely forms of entertainment. They’re not seen as transformative forces that can change a human being; that can change a society. They are seen as simple entertainment; things with which we can fill 20 minutes, half an hour, while we’re waiting to die. It’s not the job of the artist to give the audience what the audience wants. If the audience knew what they needed, then they wouldn’t be the audience. They would be the artists. It is the job of artists to give the audience what they need.

-Alan Moore