Re:The Ph.D. Problem
by stcredzero on Monday November 02, 2009 @08:45PM
(#918383)
Conformity is a big problem.
What was the big heresy for one generation changes into "what you have to say to get tenure" in another.
You are 100% on point.
The parent's poster's point on conformity is well taken. Still, "independent" researchers are viewed with suspicion because research is hard. As psranga points out, to make a long jump a researcher has to stay on top of the incremental steps. Unfortunately, for 99.9% of people, to do this they must be fluent with the literature and much more importantly talk with other researchers. No one works in a vacuum (and don't bother bringing up counter examples like einstein or newton).
Conformity is a big problem. It might arise when too many PhDs are hustling for a small pie. I'm not sure.