News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by mpk on Monday November 02, 2009 @11:35AM (#917103)
This is going to make a lot of people very upset. But really, news like this becomes a lot easier to swallow once you simply accept that Apple is a proprietary platform that works really hard at vendor lock-in.
Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by axod on Monday November 02, 2009 @12:11PM (#917239)
Or, you accept that their main focus, is making the software work with the hardware they say it works with :/

Do you also bemoan linksys for releasing firmware updates that only work with linksys products and not others?

Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by likpok on Monday November 02, 2009 @12:37PM (#917313)
Atom is x86. So it should work with Atom. That it doesn't is a sign that they are (probably) deliberately checking.
Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by axod on Monday November 02, 2009 @12:54PM (#917356)
I'd be surprised if they did't do sanity checks to ensure the hardware is what they expect it to be.
Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by pyre on Monday November 02, 2009 @01:26PM (#917459)
Why? If it's not Apple hardware ('what they expect it to be') then they don't support it. So why spend the time to check if you're on non-Apple hardware, and then pop up a nice "Unsupported hardware" (or similar) error message? Unless, of course, you're trying to prevent non-Apple hardware, but that goes without saying.

If you only support one platform, you just need to make sure that it works on that platform. People that try to run it on another platform are on their own if it breaks something/corrupts their data/etc just because you didn't do some sanity check somewhere. Putting that sanity check in is work on top of supporting your target platform (because your target platform will already be 'sane' by definition).

[Note: I'm just arguing against axod's sanity checks surprise, not necessarily anything to do with the article]

Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by tvon on Monday November 02, 2009 @12:05PM (#917208)
This is not vendor lock-in (if anything it's vendor lock-out, if anyone were to coin such a silly term).

It is difficult to switch to Apple hardware, but switching away is as easy as installing Windows on a Mac.

Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by pyre on Monday November 02, 2009 @01:28PM (#917464)
> It is difficult to switch to Apple hardware

No it isn't. It's no different than getting a new computer, and then putting Windows on it. I think you meant OSX, not 'Apple hardware.'

Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by tvon on Monday November 02, 2009 @02:58PM (#917740)
Ah yes, I'm treating them as one in the same but I did mean OSX specifically and not just the hardware.
Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by rbanffy on Monday November 02, 2009 @12:09PM (#917227)
I am not sure how can anyone in his right mind claim this is unexpected. Apple has always been one of the more closed companies in this market. It's is the only remaining computer maker from the 70s/80s that makes its own exclusive platform. The fact it uses a somewhat open Unix is a historical accident: Steve Jobs wanted to enter the Unix workstation market with NeXT and it had to be Unix-based.
Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by axod on Monday November 02, 2009 @12:12PM (#917249)
>> "The fact it uses a somewhat open Unix is a historical accident"

I don't think macs would be anywhere near as popular as they are today if this wasn't the case. I would not be using one now if it wasn't 'unixy'.

Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by rbanffy on Monday November 02, 2009 @02:14PM (#917613)
Even if every Mac user here in HN used Macs because of their Unix core, that would be very little compared to the average user. To the average Mac user, OSX is nice despite its Unix heritage.
Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by tvon on Monday November 02, 2009 @12:23PM (#917273)
You're saying that Jobs made a decision to create a Unix workstation so it's just a happy accident that he had to use Unix to make a Unix workstation?
Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by elblanco on Monday November 02, 2009 @01:52PM (#917543)
It's a happy accident that when Jobs returned to Apple, he brought the NeXT OS stack with him and had Apple stick a decent GUI on the front end that turned into OSX.
Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by tvon on Monday November 02, 2009 @02:16PM (#917617)
Apple purchased NeXT with the explicit goal of making it the core of their next generation system. I fail to see how that can be called an accident.
Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by rbanffy on Monday November 02, 2009 @07:27PM (#918283)
The accident is that they were desperate and would have bought any decent OS they could to replace the gigantic failure Copland was. NeXT had the one with the more eloquent salesman and the only person who could have given back any semblance of credibility to Apple's lineup.

Were NeXT based on VMS, Amiga, TOS, MP/M or anything like it, that would be OSXs base.

Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by elblanco on Monday November 02, 2009 @08:34PM (#918365)
They should have gone with Plan-9 ;)
Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by rbanffy on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @07:19AM (#919116)
You said it jokingly, but I think this x86 world where the OS-space seems divided between a bastard child of VMS and variants of Unix is unbelievably boring.
Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by elblanco on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @02:54PM (#920096)
Years ago in my undergrad I took a most excellent OS course offered by the indomitable Peter Denning. As presented, his course basically considered each part of an OS, chose the best of alternatives for core system concepts, and built the OS from there. The result was something not grossly unlike a modern nix, but still leaving enough wiggle room for the large number of variants we see today.

His comparisons between the way these concepts were instantiated in an nix and in other OSs were particularly good (and scathing).

That being said, it is a pity that there aren't still a dozen or so major OSes out there, each coming from a completely different approach, oh the days when an Amiga or a BeBox were interesting consumer choices. You can still find lots of minor OS variants around, but they are very small communities and it's really all boiled down to a very small and "boring" handful.

Additionally, most new OS approaches suffer from a distinct lack of software. And slowly but surely we find the inevitable creep of software Ports into new OSs, using bringing *nix like infrastructure in with them.

Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by tvon on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @05:02PM (#920396)
I believe the primary alternative to NeXT was Be Inc., that might have been interesting.
Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by rbanffy on Monday November 02, 2009 @01:31PM (#917475)
It's a historic accident Apple currently uses NeXT's OS as the foundation of OSX. Before that, Apple failed miserably a couple times trying to make a better OS upon classic MacOS.

And mind you they once did A/UX...