I have one of the original AIBOs. (Demand was so high they had a lottery to distribute them. Put in my order thinking I couldn't win the 1:13 chance, but did.)
After getting married, I stopped using it for a while (other preoccupations), leaving it sitting on the charger in the living room. We got a real puppy. After little Teddy settled in, I turned on the AIBO. O. M. G. Teddy freaked out. Pretty much the same reaction as if your chair just suddenly started wandering around the room by itself. AIBO promptly got shelved.
Medical care robots, for example, lack the disgruntled attitudes cited by elderly patients. Robotic dogs are there to play when you want to play with them, and can be easily stowed away when you don't.
I found it both fascinating and disconcerting how easily people seem to accept robots instead of other people in a variety of relations.
Two dogs? No dogs?
>No dogs?
Maybe. I like having a dog, but would like a better way to interact with her while I'm at work and other scenarios (people who wants pets but cant care for them like the elderly or the allergic or the relatively poor).
The $59 robots at the toy store really aren't the same thing. You need more than a trivial amount of intelligence and movement.
We need a robot pet startup here. Hardware is tough but if this thing sold under $500 and was at least as intelligent as the Aibo, I could see it selling in large numbers.
I also find it pleasing that Japan's religious structures are so flexible that a robot funeral isn't a big deal. In the largely dogmatic West, it would be a scandal if, say, a Catholic priest attempted this.