News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by xal on Monday November 02, 2009 @11:25AM (#917079)
It's really quite straight forward: Buy a Mac if you want OSX.

It's great to spend money on something that you enjoy!

Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by unalone on Monday November 02, 2009 @12:12PM (#917247)
Jesus, you got downvoted hard. Damn shame.

Guys, it's really, really not that difficult. Apple offers you a combination hardware/software package. They design the software to work brilliantly with the hardware they design, and they work very hard to make sure your experience is the best imaginable. That's why they pair the two together. And Apple doesn't want you using their software on hardware it wasn't designed for, because they want to make sure you get their full experience. They're designers. They win international awards for their computers. They want you to get their product, not a hybrid of half of their idea with half of somebody else's cheap refuse.

If you don't use OS X, you don't miss out on that much. It's not like you need OS X to live, and Apple's depriving you of something by asking you use their computer. If you don't want a Mac, then use Linux or Windows. If you want Apple's product, buy Apple's product, not a cheap third-rate knockoff.

In return, when you buy a high-end Mac, you get a superb, pleasurable experience. For as low as, what, six hundred dollars now?, you get a beautiful piece of hardware that does what you want it to splendidly, has the best third-party ecosystem I've ever come across, and doesn't lose you cred among any fashionistas you might know, plus it runs on Unix so you can tinker away with it however you see it. It's a very nice machine and millions of man-hours were spent making it, so perhaps it's worth your saving up a little money to purchase the full package. I and many other Mac owners can testify that we are very happy with our buy and may buy another one in the distant future.

I know the line of thought is that computers are just tools to get a job done, but that's like saying all a chair has to be is a plank of wood to get your ass on. There are planks of wood, and then there are chairs that lots of thought has gone into to make you as happy as you can be. We pay more for those chairs because while we don't need it to live, it makes our lives a little better. That's how Mac OS X's been made, and I don't think it's ridiculous to ask that we honor its maker's wishes, or at the very least, not bitch when the maker puts a little effort into ensuring you do it their way.

Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by rbanffy on Monday November 02, 2009 @01:42PM (#917513)
I have to disagree Apple wants to make the experience the best possible. For instance, I spent a couple hours trying to make Munin work on a Mac and all I could monitor from the main computer was disk space and a couple other things I don't use. The lack of up-to-date versions (they don't update stuff between major OS releases) and the lack of proper package management (ports is subminimal) drive me crazy.

And that's precisely why my Mac ended up being my "play" computer. It runs iTunes and syncs my iPod like nothing else can.

And, BTW, when I updated my iPod, one of my _cables_ (yes - a cable) stopped working because it's "not supported". What evil mind besides Apple's would consider DRM-cripple cables?

No... Macs are pleasing, but Apple doesn't aim to please it's clients above anything else. It strikes a balance between profit and an as-abusive-as-possible relationship with its customers.

Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by drewcrawford on Monday November 02, 2009 @12:47PM (#917332)
It's interesting to see how many people support Pre syncing but not hackintoshing (not an observation about you, just an observation about hackers in general).

I can't figure out why hackintoshing has such a bad name in the hacking community. I would imagine that hacking, the art of using things in clever and unintended ways, would be a great fit with osx86.

Plus the osx86 guys are some of the smartest I know. The good people contribute to Darwin and the other core Apple projects and their code ends up in mainline os x. Hackintosh users are some of the most prolific driver writers and help get tons of USB drivers written that are useful to macs and osx86 machines alike.

There's something really satisfying about building a mac, the same way there's something satisfying about building a linux or a windows box. Apple's DRM just makes it more fun.

I really don't understand the hate.

Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by Zev on Monday November 02, 2009 @03:53PM (#917892)
The good people contribute to Darwin and the other core Apple projects and their code ends up in mainline os x.

Could you link to some commits on Macosforge that were based on patches by people from osx86? This is the first I'm hearing of this.

Hackintosh users are some of the most prolific driver writers and help get tons of USB drivers written that are useful to macs and osx86 machines alike.

Last time I looked at osx86 (admittedly, years ago, long before Leopard was released), there weren't any custom kexts written by the community, just plists from Apple that were edited. Can you link to some custom kext's that have risen from osx86?

Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by drewcrawford on Friday November 06, 2009 @06:33AM (#925834)
> Could you link to some commits on Macosforge that were based on patches by people from osx86?

There are cases that I'm aware of, but I think several Apple employees would fear retaliation if I outed them here :-)

It's too bad that the XNU development process is totally closed (even if the code is OSS), as that's where you see so much of the osx86 activity. In particular, go look at voodooxnu, xnu-dev, etc. These are all drop-in replacement kernels for mach_kernel, run by hackintoshers, that accept patches from contributors. I believe voodoo will be the default kernel for the next PureDarwin (the new OpenDarwin) release.

> Can you link to some custom kext's that have risen from osx86?

http://code.google.com/p/voodoohda/ http://code.google.com/p/voodoo-power/

Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by Zev on Saturday November 07, 2009 @03:30AM (#927664)
These are all drop-in replacement kernels for mach_kernel, run by hackintoshers, that accept patches from contributors

It sounds like none of these modifications are sent back to Apple. Its great that they can fork projects - that much, anyone can do. The original claim was that osx86 hackers had contributed code to Apple, that was now in Darwin and is used in shipping OS's. Thats far more interesting then any modification that's made on a fork.

And of the two kext's you linked to, they both look to be dead in development, with more then a few major bugs each. Thats more of a hinderance than a help for your argument, really.

Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by drewcrawford on Sunday December 20, 2009 @03:19PM (#1006518)
> And of the two kext's you linked to, they both look to be dead in development, with more then a few major bugs each

I use both of those drivers daily on three different machines. I have yet to experience a single bug on my hardware. For bleeding-edge chipsets, YMMV.

As for speed of development, I generally install drivers (as opposed to userland software) once and forget about it unless there's a problem. Given that I have no problems, I'm quite satisfied.

Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by jrockway on Monday November 02, 2009 @12:08PM (#917217)
There are no 9" or 10" Macs. It's not so great to carry around a 13" laptop when you want a 9" one.

(Fortunately, Linux doesn't have this problem. It supports Atom out of the box.)

Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by axod on Monday November 02, 2009 @12:28PM (#917281)
That's what an iPhone is for.

ok,ok there's a gap for a 9-10" macbook. They should make one.

Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by SwellJoe on Monday November 02, 2009 @12:36PM (#917307)
How is an iPhone a 9" laptop?
Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by axod on Monday November 02, 2009 @01:10PM (#917407)
It kinda fits the gap for me. In terms of functionality, it's a netbook pretty much. The only difference is it's got a smaller screen, and a touchscreen instead of keyboard. Sure, it takes a little more fiddling, but I can easily ssh to servers, and fix things from my iphone, as well as any webapp/website things I need to do.
Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by SwellJoe on Monday November 02, 2009 @01:27PM (#917462)
The only difference is it's got a smaller screen, and a touchscreen instead of keyboard.

Which are huge differences. Sure, I've had an ssh client on my phone for about six years now (Sidekick II first, and now a G1), but I can't do work on my phone, even though it has a reasonable keyboard for such a small device. But, my Mini 9 is actually a pretty reasonable device for most of the work I do, up to and including development (though its obvious sweet spot is email and forums and such, which I do a lot of since support is a huge part of my business; and using the phone would be way too slow). I wouldn't consider it a replacement for the big 15" lappy or my desktop machine for serious development or graphics work or whatever, but when I am travelling light, it's exactly the right size and form-factor.

Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by unalone on Monday November 02, 2009 @01:07PM (#917396)
What axod was suggesting was that the people who need a laptop that small might be well off with what the iPhone's capable of. Certainly my iPod touch is what I use when I'm on the move, and it's capable of everything up to responding to people on Hacker News.
Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by jrockway on Monday November 02, 2009 @02:59PM (#917744)
Capable but not pleasant. Using my netbook is like using a slightly-slower version of my desktop machine. No compromises. (I carry around my HHKB with it, so the input experience is the same.)
Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by rsheridan6 on Monday November 02, 2009 @12:11PM (#917238)
corollary: if you don't want to spend money, there's always Linux and BSD.
Re:Snow Leopard Update Blocks Intel Atom, Kills Hackintosh by rbanffy on Monday November 02, 2009 @02:17PM (#917620)
Don't forget OpenSolaris. Unlike OSX, it has ZFS.