News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Low End Dedicated Servers by JeremyChase on Monday November 02, 2009 @11:22AM (#917066)
An unmentioned benefit of a dedicated server is that you aren't forced to use Linux. Many support FreeBSD, and a few will allow you to run anything you can install; OpenBSD, NetBSD, x86 Solaris, or even Windows.
Re:Low End Dedicated Servers by lsc on Monday November 02, 2009 @02:55PM (#917729)
I agree with you, but to be fair, NetBSD and OpenSolaris run quite well as a paravirtualized xen guests. (irritatingly, most providers don't support them. Even I don't support OpenSolaris, due to bootloader weirdness I haven't quite figured out how to safely integrate into my system.)

There are also obvious security benefits to running on unshared physical hardware, as Theo likes to point out.

Re:Low End Dedicated Servers by JoachimSchipper on Monday November 02, 2009 @08:09PM (#918328)
I can personally attest to the fact that ServerPronto, at least, lets you run OpenBSD. (Of course, you'll have to upgrade from their very old version yourself, and I presume support won't know much about it. But it works, about as well as can be expected for the price, and most virtualization doesn't.)
Re:Low End Dedicated Servers by lamnk on Monday November 02, 2009 @07:57PM (#918316)
AFAIK you can run FreeBSD and of course Windows on KVM

The only requirement is your CPU's full virtualization support. A lot of CPU recently are capaple of hardware virtualization, except low end processors.

Re:Low End Dedicated Servers by lsc on Monday November 02, 2009 @11:26PM (#918586)
you can under HVM mode in xen, too. Full virtualization, though, in it's current state, is inferior to paravirtualization. Significantly so. This may change as hardware advances, but right now, you are much better off going with something that can run paravirtualized.
Re:Low End Dedicated Servers by lamnk on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @09:37AM (#919347)
Full virtualization, though, in it's current state, is inferior to paravirtualization

Do you have benchmarks to back it up ? Is performance the reason to choose Xen over KVM and other virtualization technologies for your hosting company ?

Some benchmarks after quick google:

http://virt.kernelnewbies.org/XenVsKVM

Re:Low End Dedicated Servers by lsc on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @03:49PM (#920256)
reliability even more than performance. KVM was not even close to production ready in '05. HVM mode under xen was also crap. I expect 3 year uptime; running some 'qemu with hardware support' (which really is what both xen hvm and quemu are) just could not deliver that at the time.

Also emulated devices leave a much larger attack surface from the domU -> dom0 host.

I am sure that KVM has improved a whole lot in the last few years, but most of the people using it seem to be using it for 'primarily use box as hardware, spin up a virtual to test something' (this, I think, is why the kernel guys like it so much... that is what they need, and KVM is much better than Xen if that is your use case.) I really need a 'dedicated virtualization server' - the hardware only exists to service virtuals.

If I had some time, I'd do some benchmarks; I'd be interested to see what the backends the kernelnewbies bench uses... for example using tap: or phy: is sometimes an order of magnitude less bad than using file:// (of course, sometimes you get caching going in the dom0, and file:/ looks faster, but it's still a really bad idea.)

I did start with FreeBSD jails, but switched to xen after I found just what a bad idea sharing pagecache is.

Re:Low End Dedicated Servers by mynameishere on Monday November 02, 2009 @07:23PM (#918276)