News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Ph.D. Problem by foldr on Monday November 02, 2009 @10:30AM (#916947)
This is just what professional disciplines tend to be like, as the author notes. You might just as well say that "the main product of structural engineering is not the production of bridges but the reproduction of structural engineering." It's probably true in the same sense that it's true of academia, but so what?
Re:The Ph.D. Problem by gruseom on Monday November 02, 2009 @10:53AM (#916990)
There's a principle associated with some famous sociologist that says "The purpose of any institution is first to perpetuate itself, and only secondarily to pursue its specified goal." I wish I could remember who said this. It's an idea with explanatory power.
Re:The Ph.D. Problem by amichail on Monday November 02, 2009 @10:59AM (#917002)
In a related way, the purpose of a student is to maximize his/her grades and in so doing learn a few things along the way.
Re:The Ph.D. Problem by gruseom on Monday November 02, 2009 @11:07AM (#917023)
Totally disagree. I had contempt for students like that when I was in school. Probably still do, if I thought about it.
Re:The Ph.D. Problem by amichail on Monday November 02, 2009 @11:17AM (#917050)
If you don't want students to think in that way, you need to change the system.
Re:The Ph.D. Problem by gruseom on Monday November 02, 2009 @11:32AM (#917094)
Much easier to just avoid people who don't like learning.
Re:The Ph.D. Problem by RK on Monday November 02, 2009 @02:26PM (#917650)
Premeds!

I remember a never ending discussion when I was in college about why the premeds tended to get better average grades in organic chemistry than the chemistry majors, even though the chemistry majors seemed to have a much better grasp of the material.

Re:The Ph.D. Problem by sethg on Monday November 02, 2009 @03:01PM (#917749)
My wife, a former chemistry TA, would probably answer that question with one word: "Cheating."

She fears for the day she wakes up on a gurney and sees one of her former pre-med students.

Re:The Ph.D. Problem by ejames on Monday November 02, 2009 @11:30AM (#917088)
I would call that the pathological case rather than the average one. Maximizing grades against learning as little as possible is the lowest hurdle you can cross while still technically being successful as a student.

It's also worth remembering that "student" does not always mean "child currently undergoing mandatory education". I would think that adults who return to complete their diplomas/degrees or add a graduate-level program on top of the undergraduate one are comparatively more likely to choose to maximize knowledge rather than just grades. It's mostly commonly expressed as "now that I'm personally paying for it, I want to get my money's worth".

Re:The Ph.D. Problem by timwiseman on Monday November 02, 2009 @12:14PM (#917257)
This was not my experience as an undergrad. I needed a B average to keep my scholarship, so I made sure that was never at risk. Beyond that, I focused on learning and on learning what I was interested in. I spent vast amounts of time on math and computer classes and read as much as time permitted beyond the required materials. On the other hand, I only did the minimum to get the B when I had to fulfill requirements in humanities.
Re:The Ph.D. Problem by Gupie on Monday November 02, 2009 @10:51AM (#916989)
Structural engineers produce bridges, even if they are arguably just a side produce. In the worst case academics only produce academics.
Re:The Ph.D. Problem by Agathos on Monday November 02, 2009 @11:28AM (#917083)
In the worst case, structural engineers don't produce bridges. I'm sure you could find some poor soul who spent a career drawing up proposals for bridges that were never built.
Re:The Ph.D. Problem by btilly on Monday November 02, 2009 @04:26PM (#917975)
I knew an architect whose job was designing buildings that never got built.

He worked for a company that would buy residential land, he'd design a commercial building for that land, the company would take the plans to the local city council and get it rezoned, then the company would flip the newly rezoned land at a significant profit.

I liked him, but not his job or employer.

Re:The Ph.D. Problem by mquander on Monday November 02, 2009 @11:00AM (#917004)
Academics also advance humanity's knowledge in their field through research and writing, so that others may stand on their shoulders and see further. Perhaps you don't believe that things like critical literary analysis are providing us any actual benefit, but I disagree and I'm sure that any humanities professor would disagree too.
Re:The Ph.D. Problem by RyanMcGreal on Monday November 02, 2009 @11:28AM (#917085)
I'm sincerely curious to hear your case in defence of critical literary analysis.
Re:The Ph.D. Problem by foldr on Monday November 02, 2009 @01:42PM (#917510)
Why would it need any defense? Are you seriously suggesting that no-one should be reading literature and analyzing it? It's been an important part of Western culture for a few thousand years. Seems like it would be a bit rash to give it up now.
Re:The Ph.D. Problem by nkurz on Monday November 02, 2009 @02:02PM (#917573)
Despite the literal intepretation, you might be mistaken in assuming that "critical literary analysis" is the same as "reading literature and analyzing it".

Instead, I think the phrase is being used here as a term of the art, referring to something closer to "postmodern critical theory".

There are definitely those who wonder if this is useful. I too would be interested in hearing a defense.

Re:The Ph.D. Problem by foldr on Monday November 02, 2009 @09:18PM (#918431)
Most of the people who whine about postmodern critical theory haven't even read any, so I'm not sure how to give a defense of work which people haven't read. I expect that most of it is rather low in quality, but most of the work done in every discipline is rather low in quality. And in any case, not all literary criticism in the academy is "postmodern" in the invidious sense.

>Instead, I think the phrase ["critical literary analysis"] is being used here as a term of the art,

There is no such term of art, as a quick google scholar search would tell you, so I see no reason not to interpret the OP literally.

Re:The Ph.D. Problem by nkurz on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @02:04AM (#918799)
I see no reason not to interpret the OP literally

Well, luckily even a casual adherence to postmodernism gives you that right! But in my old fashioned manner, I still think intentionality counts for something, and I don't think the author intended to say that we should give up on reading. :)

Most of the people who whine about postmodern critical theory haven't even read any

I actually have read a fair bit, and periodically urge it on others, likely in the same way that some people turn their friends onto LSD. Much of it is junk, but some of it is gold. For example, Michel Foucault's "History of Sexuality Volume 1" and "Discipline and Punish" permanently changed the way I see the world around me.

So when I said I'd like to see a defense, I meant only that -- that I'd enjoy it. And, of course, that John F. Kennedy was not a homosexual: http://www.info.ucl.ac.be/~pvr/decon.html

Re:The Ph.D. Problem by foldr on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @02:19AM (#921249)
>and I don't think the author intended to say that we should give up on reading. :)

He did, however, seem to be saying that we should give up on literary criticism, which is a different thing -- you shouldn't even need a google search to tell you the difference between reading and analyzing :) It was s a stupid thing of him to say, but then I've heard quite a few scientists say it, and I'm quite willing to believe that he meant it.

>Much of it is junk, but some of it is gold.

So, why are you asking for a defense of it? Isn't the fact that some of it "changed the way you see the world around you" enough of a defense?

Re:The Ph.D. Problem by timwiseman on Monday November 02, 2009 @05:40PM (#918133)
I believe he was asking for the defense of literary criticism's value to society. If people want to analyze literature they have every right to. The question is, have they added anything of value to society?

Personally, I find it a question I have no answer to. I clearly see the value of medical doctor's, physicists, engineers. They all contribute to society in obvious ways. Liberary criticism may very well be of great value to society, but it is not in any way that is obvious to me and I sincerely would be interested if someone could provide an explanation for how it is of value to society.

Re:The Ph.D. Problem by foldr on Monday November 02, 2009 @09:16PM (#918427)
> I believe he was asking for the defense of literary criticism's value to society.

It's valuable because people are, and have always been, interested in discussing and analyzing literature in order to gain a better understanding of it. I'm not sure why you think that it has to "contribute" some definite thing to society in order to be valuable. Music and art don't obviously contribute anything either, but presumably you don't think these are without value.

>The question is, have they added anything of value to society?

Yes, they have added a greater knowledge of literature and how it works. I don't think it's necessary (or possible, really) to argue that knowledge is valuable to society. But I think the way you pose the question is a bit odd. Why does literary criticism have to "add" something distinct from itself to society in order to be valuable? Some things are valuable in and of themselves.

Re:The Ph.D. Problem by timwiseman on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @12:50AM (#918710)
It's valuable because people are, and have always been, interested in discussing and analyzing literature in order to gain a better understanding of it. ... Music and art don't obviously contribute anything either, but presumably you don't think these are without value.

But people can discus and analyze literature without there being a formal discipline for it. In fact arguable your average person could do it better without the formal discipline because they would not have be concerned about if they were doing it "right"

The analogy to music and art appears false, they do contribute things other than themselves. They contribute first entertainment, second the ties that bind culture together, and third (at least in some cases) they provide an introspection on society. Art and music add all of those things, but at least as I understand it now, literary criticism as an academic discipline provides none of them. As I have very limited knowledge of literary criticism please let me know if I am missing something.

* Some things are valuable in and of themselves.*

An interesting possibility, but it is not obvious that it is true. (I am not claiming it is false, merely that it demands justification). At least one argument is that things are valuable precisely in proportion to their utility to mankind. Excluding those people who make their living at it directly, I am unclear as to what value literary criticism provides to anyone else.

Re:The Ph.D. Problem by foldr on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @02:22AM (#921254)
>But people can discus and analyze literature without there being a formal discipline for it.

People can do anything without there being a formal discipline for it. I'm not sure what your point is here. As with most other subjects (e.g. physics, chemistry, history) extensive training in a professional environment is one moderately effective means of getting people to produce high quality work.

> In fact arguable your average person could do it better without the formal discipline because they would not have be concerned about if they were doing it "right"

No, this is not arguable. Average people suck at literary criticism in more or less the same way that average people suck at theoretical physics. Given that you admit to knowing nothing about literary criticism, so I'm curious to know how you can be so sure of what you say here.

> They contribute first entertainment, second the ties that bind culture together, and third (at least in some cases) they provide an introspection on society.

At the very least, literary criticism provides introspection on society. The first two things you mention are a little more vague (and in any case, don't apply to most work in the sciences).

>An interesting possibility, but it is not obvious that it is true.

It is obviously true in the sense that if nothing has value in itself, then you get an infinite regress. It can't be that everything is valuable only in terms of some other thing. (Of course, an infinite regress is mathematically conceivable, it just doesn't seem plausible in this particular case.)

>At least one argument is that things are valuable precisely in proportion to their utility to mankind

If you think this then you clearly agree with me that there is something that is valuable in and of itself (i.e. utility to mankind). But valuing utility above everything else is clearly wrong. For example, beauty, love and compassion would be valuable whether or not they had utility.

>Excluding those people who make their living at it directly, I am unclear as to what value literary criticism provides to anyone else.

It provides value to people who value literary criticism. And there are certainly some such people who are not literary critics. (You yourself are clearly not one of these people, but you are not the only person in the world...)

Re:The Ph.D. Problem by timwiseman on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @08:35AM (#921614)
Average people suck at literary criticism in more or less the same way that average people suck at theoretical physics. Given that you admit to knowing nothing about literary criticism, so I'm curious to know how you can be so sure of what you say here.

In theoretical physics there is an absolute authority by which to judge what is good and bad, namely the degree to which it conforms to reality. Appealing to this authority may be challenging and may not ever be practical, but it exists and it therefore means something specific to say something is wrong in theoretical physics. Also, when that theoretical physics is later applied being wrong about it can be have real negative consequences.

It is not clear to me that saying something is wrong in literary criticism even has a meaning, and even less clear that it would ever matter if something was wrong.

If you think this then you clearly agree with me that there is something that is valuable in and of itself (i.e. utility to mankind). But valuing utility above everything else is clearly wrong. For example, beauty, love and compassion would be valuable whether or not they had utility.

I actually do agree with you that some things (including beauty, truth, and love) have intrinsic value. But I take that belief starting from a Christian view point. If one were to examine it a priori or from an athiestic viewpoint it is not at all obvious or clear that anything has a value outside of its practical utility to mankind.

Re:The Ph.D. Problem by foldr on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @01:55PM (#922321)
>In theoretical physics there is an absolute authority by which to judge what is good and bad, namely the degree to which it conforms to reality.

There might be an absolute authority of this sort if we could just ask God whether or not a given theory conformed to reality, but in practice there is no absolute authority for judging work in science -- and you certainly find plenty of disagreement between scientists once you go beyond textbook material. Personally, I'm not a complete subjectivist about aesthetic and critical judgments, so I think that an "absolute standard" exists in principle for a lot of work in the humanities. For example, I think it is a fact that Jane Austen wrote good novels. However, I'm a little uneasy about your reliance on the correspondence theory of truth (the idea that a true theory is one which is some obscure sense "conforms" or "corresponds" to reality). Although I am not a skeptic or subjectivist about truth, there are well known problems with conceiving truth in this way.

> Also, when that theoretical physics is later applied being wrong about it can be have real negative consequences.

Being wrong about the kinds of subjects that the humanities touches on (e.g. relations between human beings) can also have real negative consequences, if you are not a robot.

>It is not clear to me that saying something is wrong in literary criticism even has a meaning, and even less clear that it would ever matter if something was wrong.

I'm sorry that these things aren't clear to you, but the notion that critical and aesthetic judgments are "meaningless" is one that's been thoroughly discredited over the past 50 years. Logical positivism has been dead for quite some time now.

>If one were to examine it a priori or from an athiestic viewpoint it is not at all obvious or clear that anything has a value outside of its practical utility to mankind.

Again, if you believe that, then you believe that there is something which has intrinsic value -- utility. In any case, it's not clear to me why someone looking at things from an atheistic viewpoint would choose utility as his yardstick for value. I'm an atheist and I value a whole bunch of different things. I do value things for being useful, but I don't give utility any privileged place, or see any reason to do so.

Re:The Ph.D. Problem by timwiseman on Thursday November 05, 2009 @09:18AM (#923819)
You do make some interesting points.

There might be an absolute authority of this sort if we could just ask God whether or not a given theory conformed to reality, but in practice there is no absolute authority for judging work in science -- and you certainly find plenty of disagreement between scientists once you go beyond textbook material.

Yes, you certainly do, even in the text book material. In fact, we have much better theories than Newton's Three Laws of Motion, but they are still taught because they are close enough for almost all practical applications and much simpler than appeals to relatively. But, even if reality does not always yield its secrets easily we know it has them. It is not at all clear to me that there is an objective to literary criticism.

Being wrong about the kinds of subjects that the humanities touches on (e.g. relations between human beings) can also have real negative consequences, if you are not a robot.

We have been talking about literary criticism. Some areas of the traditional humanities are clearly of great practical value at least in some cases. I did considerable research into certain areas of history as military intelligence analyst at one time and it was of tremendous value. Similarly, the study of languages is of obvious utility, and I have already provided an overview of why I see utility in art. I do not see how a knowledge of literary criticism would help someone relate to human beings in general though and I do not yet understand any value to it other than to those who make their living at it.

I know you said that it has value to those who value it. And there is certainly some truth to that, but that is circular and does not explain why.

* but the notion that critical and aesthetic judgments are "meaningless" is one that's been thoroughly discredited over the past 50 years.*

Could you provide a reference or explanation? I am not at all trying to argue that they are meaningless, but that is far from obviously true.

gain, if you believe that, then you believe that there is something which has intrinsic value -- utility.

Actually I am saying that things which have utility have value because of that utility. That is not precisely the same thing, though I will admit at that point I am splitting hairs. I do take it as obvious (and you do not seem to disagree) that something which has utility clearly has value, but I do not see any intrinsic reason why anything without utility must have value.

Again, I personally believe from a Christian standpoint that there are such things, but it is not obvious to me.

In any case, it's not clear to me why someone looking at things from an atheistic viewpoint would choose utility as his yardstick for value.

I'm certainly not trying to say that they would. What I am saying is that there is no obvious reason that they would value other things, while it is obvious they would value utility.

Re:The Ph.D. Problem by jjs on Monday November 02, 2009 @11:08AM (#917025)
> Perhaps you don't believe that things like critical literary analysis are providing us any actual benefit, but I disagree and I'm sure that any humanities professor would disagree too.

What they'll profess in public and what they'll admit "off the record" aren't always the same thing.

Re:The Ph.D. Problem by foldr on Monday November 02, 2009 @01:50PM (#917538)
The same is true of scientists, though. I know plenty who will say disparaging things about the value of their own research "off the record."
Re:The Ph.D. Problem by jjs on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @12:23AM (#918673)
I believe it.

Scientists at least have the advantage that, even if they can't see any practical application of their research, other people can (and do!).

Re:The Ph.D. Problem by rbanffy on Monday November 02, 2009 @12:19PM (#917263)
Well... The absolute worst case here is a structural engineer producing something that looks like a bridge for some time, then becomes a very dynamic and contorted structure of concrete, metal, automobiles and mostly dead primates.
Re:The Ph.D. Problem by yummyfajitas on Monday November 02, 2009 @11:03AM (#917013)
You could make the corresponding argument for structural engineering, but it would be harder.

The corresponding statement for academia would be: "the main product of academia is not the production of ___ but..."

But what do we fill in the blank with? With structural engineering, the answer is obvious. With academia, particularly humanities academia, not so much.

Re:The Ph.D. Problem by foldr on Monday November 02, 2009 @01:45PM (#917524)
It's true that research in the humanities tends to have less definite "results" than research in the sciences, but it's daft to use that as a criticism. _Of course_ literary analysis produces less definite results than chemistry. But that doesn't mean it's not worth doing.
Re:The Ph.D. Problem by krakensden on Monday November 02, 2009 @02:50PM (#917709)
Why is it worth doing? What are its results?