Re:Sexism in Tech: Don’t Ask Me Unless You’re Ready to Call ...
by emj on Monday March 09, 2015 @04:11AM
(#9169812)
You are not really helping the issue, you are doing that "I support you, but you are so wrong".
The whole "outside observer" smells like slut shaming to me. The article talkings about how to make the social environment in tech better, the clinical definition of rape is not the issue.
Re:Sexism in Tech: Don’t Ask Me Unless You’re Ready to Call ...
by joe_the_user on Monday March 09, 2015 @01:49PM
(#9172444)
you are doing that "I support you, but you are so wrong".
I sure am.
What is the problem with that? People who have been victimized sometimes say things that are incorrect. Pretending that everything someone who has been victimized says is factually correct and credible seems is totally counter-productive, makes all rational dialog impossible and ultimately allows the strongest to impose their version of events since it produces a situation where no one cares about the facts of a situation.
-- I have no objections to saying "his sexual harassment and manipulation was worse than physical rape". I'm wholly on the side of using every means possible to stop both rape and sexual harassment in the workplace and punishing people severely for both. I'm even all in favor of punishing the wealthy for using their wealth in abusive and manipulative ways, sure.
But I think the "it was as bad as rape so we should call it rape" argument really loses potential supporters.
The problem is that redefining the term creates a situation where the outside observer will feel that they can't really verify the truth or even the substance of the claim.
I know the argument that it is wholly unfair to demand that someone who has already been victimized also speak in an exact and clinical fashion about how they have victimized. Yes, it's unfair but is still the only a believable (by an outside observer) argument is going to happen. And there really isn't any alternative to that.