Re:Lojban: A constructed language, grammatically based on Pr...
by RiderOfGiraffes on Monday November 02, 2009 @09:56AM
(#916880)
> There are no languages that are just re-coding
> of other languages.
That's true, but it's "less true" of Italian/Spanish or Russian/Bulgarian than it is of, say, Russian/Swedish. I suspect that we are in complete agreement, and might argue only about precision of expression in our opinions.And I didn't say lojban is unsuitable for communication. There are a few people who use it exclusively when communicating with each other. It is not yet ready for generic, general-purpose communication, just as the newest computer programming language isn't ready for mainstream use by those not interesting in the language so much as getting things done.
But again, I suspect we are/would be in "violent agreement" about most of these points. I contend that lojban is, regardless, mind-expandingly interesting.
For some.
Re:Lojban: A constructed language, grammatically based on Pr...
by arran4 on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @02:35AM
(#921265)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nU8DcBF-qo4
As long as the languages are relatively similar and you don't push it too hard.
I understand the idea behind Lojban but you've already conceded my point. Lojban is not a suitable language for communication.