Re:On Secretly Terrible Engineers
by kragen on Sunday March 08, 2015 @03:24PM
(#9166812)
I’ve worked with secretly terrible engineers. I’ve seen lots of code samples submitted by secretly terrible engineers. I’ve been told that putting asserts in the code is bad practice because it means that the code is making assumptions, and I’ve seen my co-workers exult because they were successfully able to change the simple implementation of an interface without having to change the client code. I’ve heard software project managers claim they’d never seen a project fail for technical reasons, and I’ve seen them openly promoting waterfall development. And if you look at the kind of abysmal nonsense that fills sites like w3schools and developerWorks, not to mention the questions on StackExchange, it’s obvious that there’s such a huge volume of Openly Terrible Engineers out there that they frequently don’t know any reasonably good engineers at all.
I’ve also had the privilege of working with a lot of really super awesome people. They didn’t work at the same companies as the total incompetents, for the most part. And they weren’t all geniuses. A lot of them were just regular schmoes who worked every day to get a little bit better.
In almost 20 years in the field, I’ve also actually been the “secretly terrible engineer” — although I’ve been pretty successful in most of my jobs, I’ve also had a couple where I just stunk.
Different people do well in different environments, and software development is a wide enough field that it has a wide variety of environments in it.
I’ve also had the privilege of working with a lot of really super awesome people. They didn’t work at the same companies as the total incompetents, for the most part. And they weren’t all geniuses. A lot of them were just regular schmoes who worked every day to get a little bit better.
In almost 20 years in the field, I’ve also actually been the “secretly terrible engineer” — although I’ve been pretty successful in most of my jobs, I’ve also had a couple where I just stunk.
Different people do well in different environments, and software development is a wide enough field that it has a wide variety of environments in it.