The point of a challenge like this is the same as the point of the Randi challenge: to provide a means to demonstrate that impossible claims are impossible (in this case, that of being able to compress truly random data, and in the case of the Randi challenge, supernatural/magical abilities such as ESP). After all, if any such claim were valid, then the claimant would be able to defeat the challenge, assuming that the stated rules are fair (and they are).
Which is to say, the point of a challenge like this is not actually to have anyone enter. It's just to be.
> This type of challenge should never be made or accepted, if financial incentives are involved, without an impartial adjudicator.
Did you read the whole page? Mike did offer an impartial adjudicator:
> I would gladly submit any such submission to an impartial ombudsman to determine the question of whether data compression has occurred.
Then again, the purpose apparently was to make crackpots put their money where their mouth is rather than spam the usegroup, so perhaps fairness isn't the best success criterium.
Mike will always be able to find an excuse not to pay. If Parrick had imposed the 'no file renaming' condition, Mike could have found another way in which to break his submission with a counter loophole.
This type of challenge should never be made or accepted, if financial incentives are involved, without an impartial adjudicator.