Re:The Hiring Post
by lordnacho on Saturday March 07, 2015 @09:32AM
(#9161865)
I've done a few online tests recently, and I was thinking of how to do a better one.
1) The main idea was to have the results of unit tests visible live. I've done a few tests where I found out I didn't get through even though the test rig says it works. It compiles, it gets the examples right, but there's some hidden test that failed. You'll never know why, even though it's probably not something surprising.
So just make it explicit. A bunch of lights for each test, a description of what the test is, and there you go.
2) That solves little problems like "given some set of numbers, how do I find some ridiculous property of those numbers?" type questions.
What you really need is something that tells you how people deal with complexity. I have a large problem, how do I solve it? There's always more than one right answer.
Here you might be better off doing some kind of subjective voting. People who are looking for work might find it comforting that other people in their situation are judging them. Or gratifying to be able to judge other people's skills. Perhaps there's some incentive structure that cleverly aligns this.
1) The main idea was to have the results of unit tests visible live. I've done a few tests where I found out I didn't get through even though the test rig says it works. It compiles, it gets the examples right, but there's some hidden test that failed. You'll never know why, even though it's probably not something surprising.
So just make it explicit. A bunch of lights for each test, a description of what the test is, and there you go.
2) That solves little problems like "given some set of numbers, how do I find some ridiculous property of those numbers?" type questions.
What you really need is something that tells you how people deal with complexity. I have a large problem, how do I solve it? There's always more than one right answer.
Here you might be better off doing some kind of subjective voting. People who are looking for work might find it comforting that other people in their situation are judging them. Or gratifying to be able to judge other people's skills. Perhaps there's some incentive structure that cleverly aligns this.