In addition, that policy seems to be pretty obvious. I definitely knew about it before I signed up, I'm sure it's signposted in the app itself, and I receive email notifications about a drive that's not plugged in.
All-in-all, seems pretty reasonable.
This is a deal-breaker for me. I have limited SSD space on my MBP, so my Lightroom catalog is on an external hard drive. I can easily go 30 days between plugging it in.
That drive contains, by a very wide margin, my most important and least replaceable files.
I have no idea how they do it, but they've been around for a fair while.
A way to alleviate the issue would be to charge a small fee per drive or per account for persistent external back ups. If it was 1-2$ a month extra for the peace of mind that a drive would always be backed up, I'd gladly pay it.
At the end of the day, you have a choice as a consumer and you went with bitcasa. I'm happy paying $5/m for unlimited backup for my main computer. All said and done it's an amazing deal, even when you consider the external drive issue.
"Bitcasa keeps all of your files secure by applying client-side, AES-256 block-level encryption before they are even uploaded to your Personal Drive. Only you have access to your content. Not even Bitcasa employees can access or determine what files are in any given user’s account."
I was a customer of theirs when they first launched beta but ever since they've been screwing with their consumer customers with seemingly little thought to the consequences and their marketing copy is dangerously deceptive.
I've since moved to SpiderOak, who are quite transparent about their security and have updated their pricing to be more competitive.