In fact, net neutrality favors large monopolistic ISPs, while possibly making them slightly easier to bear. It forces information transmission to be a commodity, ensuring that only large monopolistic commodity providers can survive. It makes it impossible for any newcomers to take market share with innovation by making innovation illegal.
Locally based networks providing fast access to their subscribers and filling in the slow times with other traffic? Illegal.
Decentralized mesh networks allowing people to "mine" cryptocurrency with a transmitter on their roof? Illegal.
Those are just two of the business models made illegal by net neutrality. I'm sure there are many more that I can't think of right now.
> Locally based networks providing fast access to their subscribers and filling in the slow times with other traffic? Illegal.
As an ISP subscriber, why would I want something other than what I decided on ?
> Decentralized mesh networks allowing people to "mine" cryptocurrency with a transmitter on their roof? Illegal.
I don't see what's illegal here. If you have a transmitter on your roof you are your own ISP. It is perfectly fine to not allow a kind of traffic if you're your own ISP.
I'll grant that it's a powerful and emotional, if utterly false, argument that they put forth.
Also, I'm not so sure there are any issues with capacity and more is being added daily. Capacity for networked devices is not like making capacity for ambulances (not his analogy but essentially his point) and firetrucks.
The second a government or any entity starts to decide what is first class, second class and n-class information and thus priority, the internet goes from a place of equality and freedom to a fascist place controlled by those who have dominion.