What surprised me about recruiting was how much more important qualification is than outreach. Without good qualification, it almost doesn't matter how good your outreach is, because you're filtering for the same highly visible easily accessible candidates every other firm is looking for. The best-priced talent is buried. What you need is ground-penetrating radar. Clever outreach schemes helped us, but what really let us make our best hires was a qualification process that allowed us to confidently ignore resumes.
We didn't just maintain our team's level of quality by ignoring resumes. We transcended it. We never could have run a resume-based process that would hire people who could use lattice math to break crypto. To hire those people, we needed to select for aptitude, not experience.
I haven't said it anywhere yet, but in case the subtext isn't clear: the person who can implement an attack for which edit/compile/debug takes 4-6 hours also does a pretty great job on every other facet of the software security job. There are aptitudes that are very good proxies for other aptitudes!
Maybe my premise of 100 candidates is incorrect based on how you did outreach?
How do we figure out which ones are serious? We talk to them, usually give them homework, and then give them work-sample tests. This is not particularly expensive for us, and gives us repeatable, relevant, apples-to-apples metrics on how qualified they are to do the work. This is, as Tom insists, surprisingly easy for us. (Not to say it's easy, but nothing about hiring is easy.)
In your post you say, "At my last firm, we had the “first-call” system. Every serious applicant got, on average, 30-45 minutes of director-level time on the phone before any screening began." You seem to continue on from that point. What happens before first-call?