News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Hiring Post by nissimk on Friday March 06, 2015 @05:17PM (#9159951)
It's funny, because to change it, you have to admit that the way you were doing it before is not effective. I've come across many people who admit that they are bad at being interviewed, but very few people I meet have admitted to being bad at interviewing others. It's incongruous with the results, because these are the same people that have hired folks that we all agree are not exhibiting the level and characteristics that they are supposedly screening for.

Good job coming up with something different. I hope it's really working out as well as you say.

Re:The Hiring Post by tptacek on Friday March 06, 2015 @05:22PM (#9159979)
I was horrible at interviews. I was a sport interviewer. I had favorite tricky questions. "Design the fastest possible traceroute" was one for a long time. "Describe the most important feature of TCP NO WRONG, IT'S CONGESTION CONTROL NITWIT". I trust my own interviewing ability least of all, which is why I sink so much time into avoiding them.
Re:The Hiring Post by pcthrowaway on Friday March 06, 2015 @06:28PM (#9160246)
Why do you feel that congestion control is so much more important than guaranteed delivery? Guaranteed delivery would have been my first thought.
Re:The Hiring Post by tptacek on Friday March 06, 2015 @06:32PM (#9160255)
Guaranteed delivery is extremely easy to provide. TFTP manages it. But think about a bunch of ethernet-connected browsers sharing a 1mb/s link; that's kind of a miracle.
Re:The Hiring Post by throwawaykf05 on Sunday March 08, 2015 @10:30AM (#9165674)
> "Design the fastest possible traceroute"

Hmm, I once took it upon myself to do exactly that (mostly using non-blocking sockets, skipping hostname lookups, etc.), but what's so "tricky" about this question? Assuming the position involved network programming, I'd consider it a good way to test someone's networking knowledge. Is the "tricky" part knowing how routers often drop ICMP replies if they exceed some threshold rate?

Re:The Hiring Post by powertower on Saturday March 07, 2015 @03:43PM (#9163050)
> I was horrible at interviews. I was a sport interviewer...

That's nowhere near as bad as the interviewer who has the primary goal of demonstrating how smart he is (to the person he is interviewing), with the actual hiring process being secondary.

Re:The Hiring Post by tptacek on Saturday March 07, 2015 @03:58PM (#9163113)
That is automatically what I think about anyone who says "I'm a very good interviewer".
Re:The Hiring Post by jfb on Friday March 06, 2015 @09:21PM (#9160706)
I am painfully aware of my limitations as an interviewer. I wish there was institutional support for interviewing as a skill distinct from more specific job requirements. I've worked at big companies, small companies, been a founder, and I've never been comfortable with engineering interviews. So, more power to tptacek in his crusade.
Re:The Hiring Post by bentcorner on Friday March 06, 2015 @05:35PM (#9160059)
I'll admit that I'm bad at interviewing others. I'm not trying to humble-brag or anything. I'm just bad at it. Part of it is that I haven't had to go through an interview in over 10 years, so it's difficult to empathize with a candidate. I do my best, though. The other part is that I'm happy at what I do, but I'm not the best. I sometimes can't keep up with candidates when they're writing on a whiteboard and make a claim that such-and-such works. I squint and can make a judgement on that claim, but really I need to cover x, y, and z during our hour together and we're already 20 minutes into it and I don't want to get dragged into the weeds.

So, I'm not a fan of giving interviews. I wouldn't mind shadowing someone better than I, but my first inclination is that that would be a terrible idea since it would make candidates even more nervous.