News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: What's the worst thing that could happen to Google? by justinsb on Sunday November 01, 2009 @09:24PM (#915953)
How about Microsoft including an ad blocker in the next Windows Update.
Re:Ask HN: What's the worst thing that could happen to Google? by chaosmachine on Sunday November 01, 2009 @11:11PM (#916104)
Google would patch their ad code to get around it in an hour, tops. It's a cat and mouse game, and Microsoft isn't a particularly fast cat.
Re:Ask HN: What's the worst thing that could happen to Google? by amalcon on Sunday November 01, 2009 @11:15PM (#916112)
There must be some contractual or legal reason for them not to. Otherwise, they'd have done it a while ago, to try to "kill" the web as a platform.

That said, yeah, this would hurt Google bad if it somehow happened.

Re:Ask HN: What's the worst thing that could happen to Google? by pieceofpeace on Monday November 02, 2009 @12:46AM (#916254)
Because MS is also into advertising that is not likely.

But if it did that Google would block Windows users' access to their services and show a message that MS is responsible for this mess _and_ sue MS for anti-competitive practices.

Re:Ask HN: What's the worst thing that could happen to Google? by tomjen2 on Monday November 02, 2009 @03:18AM (#916420)
They might not have a leg to stand on with an anti trust suit if Microsoft blocks their own ads as well.

Not that that will prevent a suit, but it would be useful as a defence.

Re:Ask HN: What's the worst thing that could happen to Google? by rubinelli on Monday November 02, 2009 @06:57AM (#916601)
Do you remember that one time when Microsoft tried to add "smart tags", keyword-based links that showed up as squiggly lines? Do you remember the uproar, even though there was a simple op-out mechanism, and how quickly they dropped the whole idea? That would be nothing compared with a bundled ad blocker.
Re:Ask HN: What's the worst thing that could happen to Google? by DougBTX on Monday November 02, 2009 @08:26AM (#916704)
There is a similar feature in IE8 called "Accelerators", but with less uproar.

http://www.microsoft.com/windows/internet-explorer/features/...

Re:Ask HN: What's the worst thing that could happen to Google? by bemmu on Sunday November 01, 2009 @09:34PM (#915967)
True, that would really hurt them. I can't even immediately come up with any reason why they couldn't do that, ad blockers are a very legit piece of software after all. Given how much sense this makes, what's been stopping MS from doing it so far?
Re:Ask HN: What's the worst thing that could happen to Google? by human_v2 on Sunday November 01, 2009 @09:41PM (#915980)
Because MS is also an advertiser. Bing would become immediately worthless to advertisers if they did. Plus, assuming MS let their ads through and blocked Google's, Google would yell "anti-competition lawsuit" faster than you can say, well, anti-competition.
Re:Ask HN: What's the worst thing that could happen to Google? by jerf on Sunday November 01, 2009 @10:18PM (#916019)
Remember the anti-trust party that was started when Microsoft started giving away a free browser in competition with Netscape? That would be nothing compared to the storm that would emerge if Microsoft tried to directly attack AdWords from its still-a-convicted-monopolist position with an action like that.
Re:Ask HN: What's the worst thing that could happen to Google? by justinsb on Sunday November 01, 2009 @10:38PM (#916046)
Agreed, but Microsoft could probably delay things for long enough to hurt Google sufficiently. It might be enough simply to auto-install it, hook customers on ad blocking, pay the fine, then send out a patch to make it opt-in only.

My guess is that at the moment it seems that the DoJ really has its eyes on Google, and Microsoft doesn't want to pull a stunt like this and distract them.

Re:Ask HN: What's the worst thing that could happen to Google? by robryan on Monday November 02, 2009 @01:39AM (#916327)
Could play into Google's hands though if they tried to directly compete against windows, they would now have a great angle to convince people why they should make the change to a more open and neutral system.
Re:Ask HN: What's the worst thing that could happen to Google? by richardw on Monday November 02, 2009 @12:30AM (#916231)
I think Google would put immense pressure on them via anti-trust if they did that.

Besides, not everyone wants all ads blocked. When I search on Firefox, I don't even see ads on the RHS of Google. Sometimes I want to and don't need MS deciding what I'll see. MS would lose huge if they did this.

Re:Ask HN: What's the worst thing that could happen to Google? by axod on Monday November 02, 2009 @04:30AM (#916488)
Because ad-blockers are trivially simple to get past.
Re:Ask HN: What's the worst thing that could happen to Google? by aaronblohowiak on Sunday November 01, 2009 @10:32PM (#916040)
Ad blockers create an unlicensed derivative work of the copyrighted works that are received, and they could likely be sued for that.
Re:Ask HN: What's the worst thing that could happen to Google? by InclinedPlane on Monday November 02, 2009 @12:15AM (#916211)
This is just silly. If you were scraping a site's content and publishing it elsewhere maybe there would be a case, but for personal use you can create as many derivative works as you like under fair use. If not then accessibility features like screen readers and magnifiers (many of which are built into browsers) would be illegal.

Users are free to modify site's content as much as they want, using adblockers or using cornify, etc. This is no different than someone cutting out parts of articles from a magazine to make their own collages. Once it's in your hands you can do what you like with it, as long as you don't republish it.

Re:Ask HN: What's the worst thing that could happen to Google? by aaronblohowiak on Monday November 02, 2009 @01:49AM (#916338)
Re:Ask HN: What's the worst thing that could happen to Google? by tsally on Sunday November 01, 2009 @11:16PM (#916114)
Plagiarism checkers that store copies of whole essays are considered fair use, so I doubt ad blockers violate copyright law.
Re:Ask HN: What's the worst thing that could happen to Google? by tumult on Sunday November 01, 2009 @11:10PM (#916101)
No, they don't.
Re:Ask HN: What's the worst thing that could happen to Google? by frig on Monday November 02, 2009 @08:36AM (#916727)
This cute legal theory hasn't been tested at web scale to my knowledge (closing down shop due to threat of lawsuit != the theory is tested, just that the depth of someone's wallet has been tested and found wanting).

What makes it curious in the web context is the following: say we can decompose the transmitted web page into the "content" and the "ads".

It is occasionally the case that the full ad content is directly embedded in the transmitted work but that is not the norm; far-and-away the most typical setup is:

- the content is transmitted as part of the page

- the ads are transmitted as scripts embedded in the page; the ads are thus not directly transmitted but if the receiving user's browser operates in a particular fashion than those scripts will execute and insert the actual ad-content into the page in a way the user can see it

If an ad-blocker works by stripping out javascript there is a smidgen of a derivative-work argument here.

If, instead, the ad-blocker works by altering the operation of the javascript interpreter (eg: leaving it unable to connect to the ad server) then nothing in the combined content+ads has been changed by the ad blocker.

If the ad-creating javascript were somehow involved in protecting the content (eg: the web page is transmitted "encrypted"; the page's javascript is waiting for a key to be transmitted in the ad content before decrypting the page content) then you might be able to work up a DMCA anti-circumvention claim, but your user experience would be so terrible it probably wouldn't make economic sense to do this.

All that said: an "ad-blocker" program is safe so long as it has substantial non-infringing uses.

Given the vast range of computers in use (in terms of cpu/ram/intended usage/etc) and given the vast range of hazards out on the internet (phishers/virii/etc.) a program that facilitates one or both of:

- "hostfile management" (blocking or restricting address to particular servers or ip ranges, etc.)

- "javascript management", adding additional checks or safety controls to how a browser interprets javascript

...is clearly going to have substantial non-infringing uses and should have a clean legal bill of health provided it is marketed as a generic security / performance solution and not an "ad-blocker".

Thus in the unlikely event that your legal theory vis-a-vis ad blocking is found to have teeth all that will be needed to continue ad blocking as before will be to rebrand the software as a more generic hostfile+javascript management with a way of sharing and importing configuration files from other users (allowing the users, then, to block ads themselves).

So as cute as it is this isn't a theory that will do much more than prevent any serious commercial ad-blocking venture from getting serious traction.

Re:Ask HN: What's the worst thing that could happen to Google? by jrockway on Sunday November 01, 2009 @10:47PM (#916065)
Fair use.
Re:Ask HN: What's the worst thing that could happen to Google? by nailer on Monday November 02, 2009 @03:54AM (#916449)
...would only cover a portion of the document.