News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Aaron Swartz's Thoughts on djb (2009) by astrodust on Friday March 06, 2015 @02:54PM (#9159177)
Qmail is far from flawless. It could be better if patches were allowed, but no, that's forbidden.

As much as DJB is a talented programmer, his attitude towards outside contributions comes across as extremely hostile.

I can't take any of the DJB projects seriously because they're always in a state of permanent abandonment and maintainers are impossible to find. They serve as art pieces more than practical, useful software.

He's certainly from the old school of development where tight control over your software ensures it's not exposed to risk from external developers, and of course he's entitled to do that. The consequence is that severely limits how this software can be used.

Re:Aaron Swartz's Thoughts on djb (2009) by tarminian on Saturday March 07, 2015 @03:39PM (#9163038)
Why should software be in a state of permanent development?

"I can't take any of the DJB projects seriously because they're always in a state of permanent abandonment and maintainers are impossible to find. They serve as art pieces more than practical, useful software."

There are plenty of "maintainers", just search for the qmail mailing list, if that is impossible then I'm not sure what to say to you, but what you say is bunk.

Re:Aaron Swartz's Thoughts on djb (2009) by astrodust on Monday March 09, 2015 @01:26PM (#9172283)
Software needs to be in a state of permanent development because nothing is static. Operating systems change. Usage patterns change.

Seeing Qmail rot on the vine is heart-breaking, but that's exactly what happened.

I used to use Qmail exclusively, but over time it got harder and harder to install an up-to-date version of it, requiring more and more "unofficial" patches to get it actually working. After too much of that I gave up and went with Postfix.

I don't want "mailing lists", I don't want Bugzilla, I don't want SourceForge. I want people that respond to something like GitHub issues where the interaction is painless and productive.

Re:Aaron Swartz's Thoughts on djb (2009) by kragen on Saturday March 07, 2015 @01:18PM (#9162531)
qmail has been in the public domain since 2007, and patches have always been allowed.

Most of your other statements seem similarly at odds with reality to me, but they’re more statements of your taste than anything else.