News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Aaron Swartz's Thoughts on djb (2009) by jedberg on Friday March 06, 2015 @12:48PM (#9158351)
DJB a software engineer who doesn't listen to other's input and believes that his way is always the right way. Despite the fact that his software is solid, I try to avoid it all costs because it is a huge pain to configure and manage and doesn't follow the UNIX way at all. It follows the DJB unix way, which is terrible if you want to use anything that isn't DJB.

Also tinydns is fundamentally broken because DJB doesn't believe in split views.

Re:Aaron Swartz's Thoughts on djb (2009) by Canada on Friday March 06, 2015 @02:28PM (#9158993)
If anything, it's a huge pain to configure and manage because his software follows the Unix way more faithfully than most Unix server software: collections of small programs that communicate over well defined interfaces.

As a programmer, it's great. The very minimal feature set and lack of high level abstractions makes the code very easy to understand and modify. The fact that everything uses stdio makes debugging really easy.

As a sysadmin it sucks because providing the features your users rightly expect forces you to maintain patches as well as configuration. And a good deal of that configuration is long pipelines where tiny changes have huge consequences. Set the magic option in the magic variable to change behavior. Certain files that aren't explicitly mentioned anywhere just have to exist, and one wrong permission or file ownership just breaks everything and it's really annoying to figure out what's wrong.

Re:Aaron Swartz's Thoughts on djb (2009) by jedberg on Friday March 06, 2015 @05:44PM (#9160082)
> his software follows the Unix way more faithfully than most Unix server software: collections of small programs that communicate over well defined interfaces.

In my worldview, that's only part of the unix way. The other part is putting the files in well known and agreed upon locations, like /usr and /usr/local and /etc. DJB software breaks these conventions.

Everything else you said is spot on.

Re:Aaron Swartz's Thoughts on djb (2009) by kragen on Saturday March 07, 2015 @01:23PM (#9162545)
The people who invented Unix disagree with you, or they would have put those files there when they wrote Plan 9.
Re:Aaron Swartz's Thoughts on djb (2009) by dsp on Friday March 06, 2015 @01:51PM (#9158726)
Are you aware of the client location (%lo) support introduced in 1.04? Since it works at a per-record level---instead of per-zone---I find it more useful than the typical split view support.

http://cr.yp.to/djbdns/tinydns-data.html

Re:Aaron Swartz's Thoughts on djb (2009) by jedberg on Friday March 06, 2015 @05:45PM (#9160087)
I wasn't aware of that, and you're right, that is probably more useful than split view. So I stand corrected on that one point, but dang if it didn't take him a long time to come around.