News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:VMWare Taken to Court Over GPL Violation by belorn on Friday March 06, 2015 @03:28AM (#9156152)
How would this problem only apply to GPL? If you do not give the 5% revenue to unreal when using their engine, I am sure they will sue. A company can not pick and choose which license agreement to follow and which to ignore, or they risk inoperation from lawsuits.

In practice, license conditions are balanced to the interest of the company. Some might be perfectly fine with 5% revenue losses in order to pay for a engine, where others would strongly disallow it. If this lawsuit succeed, my guess is that any damages will be far less than 5% total revenue from the years of Linux usage.

Re:VMWare Taken to Court Over GPL Violation by lmm on Friday March 06, 2015 @07:44AM (#9156741)
The worst cases are better with most other licenses though:

* Most of the time commercial libraries like unreal make a distinction between interface and implementation. In the worst case you could swap out their implementation and reimplement the methods you use, which will be expensive but at least at the end of it you'll have a clean codebase that you own. With GPLed code even that might not be enough - you could replace the GPLed implementation and your codebase might still be a derivative work of the GPLed library. * Epic is a profit-making business with obligations to their shareholders; ultimately resolving any issue with them is going to be "only" a matter of money, it's not in their interests for your company to go out of business. An individual GPL copyrightholder is more likely to be idealistic/spiteful about it. And GPLed libraries often have several copyrightholders, multiplying the risk.

Re:VMWare Taken to Court Over GPL Violation by the_mitsuhiko on Friday March 06, 2015 @06:28AM (#9156547)
> How would this problem only apply to GPL?

Because not many other licenses like GPL "spread" to the entirety of the project. Sure, you can draft another license like this, but out of the popular ones there really is only the (A)GPL which does that.