News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Finance novice beats hedge fund pros, winning $100k in Qu... by Terr_ on Thursday March 05, 2015 @02:46PM (#9153332)
Cautionary observation: The same company that judges the contest also makes more money when this specific kind of contestant wins.

> "With the Quantopian platform, anyone with a bit of coding skill and a mind for finance can start writing algorithms. The best ones win."

> The winning algorithm each month is deemed to be the one that, based on Quantopian’s analysis, offers the best combination of [...]

It is entirely possible that everything was aboveboard and honest, but there's still a latent conflict-of-interest since the company may have leeway choosing what constitutes the "best combination" of metrics.

Re:Finance novice beats hedge fund pros, winning $100k in Qu... by dunster on Thursday March 05, 2015 @03:22PM (#9153560)
We work very hard to make our interests aligned with our community members' interests. We don't literally make money from the algorithms in the contest. What we're doing is encouraging hundreds and thousands of new people to write algorithms. The best ones will be invited to join our hedge fund, we'll negotiate compensation with them, and we'll take investment from pension funds and endowments and the like. In that sense - yes, when our customers win, we win too.

As for the judging, I think you'll find it be very transparent. There are 6 return and risk metrics calculated for both the backtest and the paper trading. The 6 metrics are weighted equally to generate an overall score. You can see the metrics for every contestant and the combined score on the leaderboard. You can verify it all by downloading the CSV. https://www.quantopian.com/leaderboard