News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Compositional Music Composition by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday March 05, 2015 @02:28PM (#9153215)
That's because traditional music notation isn't a DSL - it's a form of shorthand that gives you the bare minimum of information needed to create an interpretation.

And if it's something like figured bass or a jazz lead sheet, it's not even close to what's actually performed.

So if you take it literarily and think it's some kind of definitive description, you miss about 90% of what's going on.

> my point basically is that the deeper you get into this, the deeper you discover it goes.

Exactly. People who know more about computers than music keep reinventing this list idea over and over.

I've literally lost count of the number of times the same concepts have appeared in different places over the decades.

The people who 'invent' them always seem very pleased that they've completely mastered a whole new problem domain.

Sadly, no. Expressive music isn't about lists of notes.

Expressive music representations and creative music theory are full-scale industrial machine learning and AI problems.

It's hard to make music that more than a hundred people, not including your friends, will pay to listen to more than once.

For me, that's the absolute non-negotiable base test for models that claim to represent music in a useful way.

Re:Compositional Music Composition by noelwelsh on Thursday March 05, 2015 @03:09PM (#9153482)
Note that Compose is designed to be a teaching aid and a fun toy, not to produce studio quality results.
Re:Compositional Music Composition by tessierashpool on Thursday March 05, 2015 @08:18PM (#9155008)
yeah, I understand that. and I think it's a cool library. the + and | thing is neat. but, fwiw, I do want to produce studio-quality results. :-)
Re:Compositional Music Composition by davegurnell on Friday March 06, 2015 @05:46AM (#9156470)
Thanks for the comments -- agreed with everything you say. I'm also a musician and the intersection between music and code is really interesting to me. Compose is just a toy, but I'm interested in learning about musical systems that are not.