But having the ability to judge if someone is a good or bad person or has a good or bad character is the part I can't wrap my head around. The inherent bias is overwhelming as this is an entirely subjective barometer) and the ramifications of playing G-d or Santa sends a screaming message that is counter to everything the post wants me to believe about YC Culture.
My definition of a good guy is someone who accepts me for who I am and doesn't pass judgement on me. I suspect most peoples judgement of good or bad character is more a relfection of how they see themselves and how the other person fits into that narrative (i.e. people want to be consistent with their beliefs, so the good/bad evaluation is based on how you perceive yourself and if this person fits into that story), versus any real indication if they are good or not.
I guess I'm saying that I am very suspect of the character and judgement of someone who thinks they are good at judging peoples character.
Edit: Just to be clear, everything I have ever heard about JL has been wonderful...but this comment about being able to judge character really rubs me the wrong way.
Edit2: Grammar, and some elaboration in ().
Which is precisely why you have to be very, very, very careful. The matter-of-fact way it was phrased in the blog post didn't give me the impression that there was a whole lot of skepticism regarding her abilities. If one does make such a grandiose claim, it seems like a person conscious that it is a grandiose claim would preface it with a whole lot of qualifiers and such.
> There was once an accidental control group though. Jessica missed about half of the interviews and PG, RTM, and Trevor were left to decide on their own. I would estimate that the error rate without her was about 2x-3x as high.
I'm curious what the sample-size is and what error-rate actually means. I realize with the control group question and this question, I risk coming off as awfully pedantic.
Speaking about unconscious bias, although this judgement can be valid, would you have said the same about say, a (male?) engineer claiming that "I can often tell good software architecture from bad". Which is a similarly subjective, heuristic-based imprecise classification problem.
Not saying you wouldn't, by the way. But I wonder if for plenty of us there are biases in play here as well, since we are talking about skills usually considered less "hard" scientifically (even though they are just as much 'hard skills' as the above example about software architecture [1]).
[1] Unless you are in the 0.00001% of developers who deal with formally specified and verified software.
This is true, but the way people go about the process of sorting out the other elements is a critical part of the analysis (pardon the wording).
I think to say such selection is an 'untractable process' strikes me as an oversimplification, as does dismissing it simpley as "something necessarily done by 'gut feel".
And I think that this (latter) oversimplification is the root of the issue that is worth discussion. This combination of elements is off-putting. It reaks of being arbitrary rather than well considered.
And so its worth more consideration.
Consider the following example.
We are to judge two Atheltes that have equal technical skills and equally strong character traits (in an objective sense), and yet we may still reject or prefer one or the other based on the fit of their respective skillsets.
With the system that is preferred by the (coach, owner, GM) of course being preferred.
That preference for style is not a preference for 'character,' (again, in the objective sense) it is simply a ... preference for the style that fits in with the ex ante preferences of the selection principals.
(not trying to be sexist and use a sports analogy, but its not really any more useful here to use YC or other VC firms as examples).
So, at one layer there is always bias towards style.
Say our team runs a fast-paced offense, that is a style-bias that is layered over technical skill and 'objective' character.[1]
YC seems to have almost made a philosophical point to form its business around some style-bias...insofar as the 'style' of millenial undergraduates cum entreprenuers in primarily male-dominated technical fiels is going to by nature exclude (of course) a wide variey of styles that clash with the 'core style'.[2]
Again, there is nothing with wrong with this style bias.
And I mean that both in the sense that there is nothing wrong with selecting for style-complementary attributes (on the one hand), nor is there anything wrong with dimensionalizing style as an explanatory variable.
Style in this sense is functional to productivity.
The upshot of this is that style is inherently <intuited> before its really comprehended rationally or analytically. This explains why style judgements seem so intuitive and 'snap', but at the same time the phrase 'rigourous sense of style' is not either un-common or innaccurate.
While 'objective' character and Style are both attributes subject to (intuitive, snap) judgement it is really best not to conflate the two.
I think we are doing the topic a dis-service by not calling out style bias as something distinct from objective character evaluation.
-------
[1] What I'll just call 'objective' character here, which has both moral and pragmatic dimensions, but you get the gist, in that its covering things like fundamental integrity, work ethic, and functional social-skills, leadership, altruism, etc).
[2] the core style being the subset of those in the target class deemed qualified enough to be alumni of YC.
I certainly hope so, although I of course can't be sure. I do think I did more than just make a bald assertion, though, by presenting an example of what I would have expected a more skeptical claim about her abilities to look like. In other words, I think I gave a characterization which could apply to either gender. Of course, whether I would have highlighted it to begin with if she were a man is a whole different matter and, like I said, I hope I would have.
My point is only that many claims subject to pretty much the same biases are usually made in HN (about hiring, about software architecture, about understanding technology/futurism) and treated with far less skepticism. That said, I am inclined to agree that the standard should be more skepticism in all cases, rather than less. With the caveat that it might not be practical up to a point.
Although, to be honest, I'd love to go into an interview with "I am X deviations above/below the mean of developer productivity in Java software analysis when compared against a sample of Y developers selected by procedure Z, measured by metric W; I am usually more productive working on teams of size n-m (p < 0.01)."
Perhaps n72 should also consider checking his privilege...
In any case, most of my emphasis was on the bias of discounting "soft skills", rather than gender bias.
The way to communicate from a country to another is really different, same for the culture, ... How do you integrate the 'foreigner' factor in the evaluation?
There was once an accidental control group though. Jessica missed about half of the interviews and PG, RTM, and Trevor were left to decide on their own. I would estimate that the error rate without her was about 2x-3x as high.
The other thing to remember is that we keep track of the startups that we interview, and for the ones that we accept, we end up working with them for many years. We make a point of studying our mistakes (and successes), so there is a feedback loop, and I believe that we're getting better at it every time. But of course there are about a million other variable in play, so it's very difficult to be certain about anything (which is part of what makes this business so interesting).