This seems to be a deeply confused comment.
What about evolution is "high" or "low"? Which is a higher form of life, the housefly, or the Neanderthal? Which one is still around?
If aliens with FTL travel and psychic powers were to visit us and start wiping us out, would their xenophobia[1] mark them as a being at a "lower" evolutionary stage? If so, what is the use of such a classification?[2]
Evolution is not always "up." For that matter, "up" isn't always "up."
"The feedback loop never really ends, so a tenth year polysentience can be a priceless jewel or a psychotic wreck," ~Alpha Centauri
[1]And if they were the ones wiping us out, who would be more "phobic" (afraid), us or them?
[2]http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/EvolutionaryLevel...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partially_ordered_set
>If aliens with FTL travel and psychic powers were to visit us and start wiping us out, would their xenophobia[1]
>[1]And if they were the ones wiping us out, somehow I doubt they'd have much of a phobia.
you're right - FTL and xenophobia are incompatible. A xenophobia indicates intellectual capabilities level not sufficient for FTL. The same about "wiping out".
>Evolution is not always "up." For that matter, "up" isn't always "up."
"up" has a pretty clear direction on many axes. For a given axis it is the direction of higher degree of symmetry breakup whatever it means on that given axis. Complexity/specialization and sentience level for biological systems. Managed energy density for technological civilization. Violence control for social organization.
A poset is ordered on one relation, and you posit (see what I did there?) that natural selection does the same, and that for humans, it just happens to be greater or lesser degrees of xenophobia?
>A xenophobia indicates intellectual capabilities level not sufficient for FTL.
I don't buy this, and I'm not sure why you do. It certainly shouldn't be taken as an axiom.
> "up" has a pretty clear direction on many axes. For a given axis it is the direction of higher degree of symmetry breakup whatever it means on that given axis. Complexity/specialization and sentience level for biological systems. Managed energy density for technological civilization. Violence control for social organization.
The problem is that the axis isn't given. One is competing on all of these axes all at the same time. And, predictably, progress along one axis may mean regress along another. What if you have a technological civilization populated by sentients with greater or lesser degrees of violence? Did you know that identity theft has increased by astronomical amounts since 1960? And yet we have these shiny iPads. Have we progressed?
I don't know what's so great about this. Is HN, a conglomeration of (mostly male) economic and educational elite, a "more evolved" state of social organization than a small-town church, which might draw in people from different economic walks of life?
in my view mentally associating yourself with any group is exactly the root of the division "us vs. them (and us obviously better [whatever that means] than them)" and things go downhill from that. In that regard any "elite" group (self-identifying itself as such) is pretty much indistinguishable from a small-town church.
as well as planet or galaxy quadrant or specific species one was born on or at. Many people/societies have evolved past the stage of the valley/tribe/village and now the most of the human species is at region and nationality state. Some advanced people were able to evolve past that. It requires letting go identification characteristics that are just given by birth and mentally moving on to what her or his truely personal identification is, ie. result of her/his personal efforts, like education, life/work experience, personal spiritual and intellectual development, etc...
> What rational basis is there
there isn't. Just our low evolutionary stage. Deeply xenophobic.