News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What's Going on at the Bay Bridge by ars on Saturday October 31, 2009 @11:11PM (#914597)
It seems to me that the eyebar was not designed correctly - it has a stress concentration point exactly where it cracked. (If you can visualize the forces acting on it, and then take the derivative you'll see the inflection point. It's important that the derivative of the forces be smooth.)

If I were making one, I'd make it in a tear shape. i.e. the shape you would get if you wrapped a rope halfway around a bar and pulled on it.

Interestingly the outside of the eyebar is (almost) the right shape. Someone filled in the inside to make it a circle. This is a mistake - the skin of metal is much stronger than the inside (that's one of the reasons cables are made of many many strands). By filling it in you are not making it stronger - you make it weaker, because now you have less skin on the inside, and additionally you have a stress concentration point.

Re:What's Going on at the Bay Bridge by NikkiA on Sunday November 01, 2009 @07:11AM (#914984)
The bay bridge was started in 1933, and construction ended in 1936. Metal fatigue and many other aspects of material science were unknown at that time. If the eyebar was original, or built to original specs, it's entirely possible that the failure mode it exhibited wasn't even predictable given 1930s knowledge of materials under stress.

So I'm not in too much of a rush to find someone to blame :)

Re:What's Going on at the Bay Bridge by hop on Sunday November 01, 2009 @12:53PM (#915312)
Unless its case hardened, which I highly doubt this steel is, the "skin" of the metal isn't stronger.

You can plainly see rust, so chemical corrosion probably started a crack, which grew through cyclical loading and more corrosion over many years.