Re:Tendermint – The completely decentralized consensus engine
by vbuterin on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @12:58AM
(#9142912)
I think you underemphasize this point. My Slasher algo ( https://blog.ethereum.org/2014/01/15/slasher-a-punitive-proo... ) from way back then does use sampling; Tendermint does not, and thus gains a whole bunch of robustness properties at some cost to efficiency.
Re:Tendermint – The completely decentralized consensus engine
by lappa on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @08:57AM
(#9144167)
>all validators must sign every block.
Well now you're defining a new system. You can't expect me to explain the security of an undefined system, so I am sticking to the system defined in your paper which states that not all validators need to sign every block.
Re:Tendermint – The completely decentralized consensus engine
by jaekwon on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @03:22PM
(#9147054)
The whitepaper says that +2/3 of the entire validator set (in voting power) must sign every block. In the ideal scenario (in other words, in the stable state) every validator does sign every block.
Re:Tendermint – The completely decentralized consensus engine
by lappa on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @04:19PM
(#9147441)
Yes, it is pointless for me to argue about an undefined system. If you mean to say that 67% of the validator set must sign every block, then you shouldn't argue with the premise that 100% must sign every block.
That notion makes sense in something like PeerCoin or other preexisting PoS designs, but I don't see how that phrase applies to Tendermint. There is no "sampling" -- all validators must sign every block.