News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Swift: Madness of Generic Integer by stcredzero on Tuesday March 03, 2015 @06:49PM (#9141624)
Generic code is like nerd sniping.

(Remove "like?")

You shouldn't use generics to magically get the compiler to magically do low level things for you. IMO, generics (specifically C++ style generics) should be used to manage things at fairly high levels of abstraction for fairly domain specific stuff. As Swift's Integers are built to prioritize performance and are fairly "close to the metal," this sort of problem is what you'd expect.

If you want to create beautiful edifices of pure mathematics, go write in Haskell. That's not what Swift or its standard library were built for.

Re:Swift: Madness of Generic Integer by viraptor on Tuesday March 03, 2015 @08:55PM (#9142223)
> You shouldn't use generics to magically get the compiler to magically do low level things for you.

Why not?

> As Swift's Integers are built to prioritize performance and are fairly "close to the metal," this sort of problem is what you'd expect.

I don't understand how one follows from the other. This is stuff that should be expanded at compilation stage, there's no runtime overhead. Likely that whole function should be specialised for each usage and be small enough to inline it. Since the loop has a known number of iterations, I even wouldn't be completely surprised if it was just a few basic instructions with array check skipped in some cases.

Re:Swift: Madness of Generic Integer by dmritard96 on Tuesday March 03, 2015 @07:40PM (#9141953)
While I agree that other languages can handle things in a cleaner way at the expense of performance, I also think that treating a smartphone with insanely powerful processors as if they are embedded devices is also a bit disappointing. Most of the worlds python code is probably running on commodity hardware with considerably less horsepower than todays smartphones. Even in python's case for instance, if you need to drop into something closer to the metal (most of the time probably unnecessary), you can quite easily.
Re:Swift: Madness of Generic Integer by stcredzero on Tuesday March 03, 2015 @08:34PM (#9142160)
I also think that treating a smartphone with insanely powerful processors as if they are embedded devices is also a bit disappointing

Computation is power, which is always going to be at a premium on mobiles in a competitive market. But if you want to have beautiful edifices of mathematics in Swift, you can always use Swift to write your own math library, and still get better performance than cpython. Expecting Swift's built in types to trivially be your math library is wishing the design goals were different.