We have the CLA to ensure this we're on the right side of copyright law. But your article looks interesting and I'll read it.
Great to hear you plan to run GitLab CE, we hope you'll enjoy it.
I appreciate that. I think you have good intentions. The author of the article is Bradley Kuhn, who works at the Software Freedom Conservancy. He's an expert when it comes to the legal aspects surrounding free software projects, so perhaps having a conversation with him about the CLA would be a worthwhile experience.
The CLA is only a license, another license than MIT, but doing _almost_ the same things. IIRC, the difference is that it gives you okay to make proprietary distributions without respecting MIT conditions.
You do not need it to be "on the right side of copyright law".
Using MIT-licensed code is on the right side of copyright law just as well. (unless what you want is to disobey poor old MIT)
The install could use a bit of work, and setting up the repo hosting was somewhat tricky to understand the documents (various users and sudo lines to create). But overall it's pretty fantastic.
> I guess I will just self-host my own GitLab CE instance now.
I moved from Google Code to a forked version of indefero[1]. I would be happy to post the link but I don't want to be a shameless post. Indefero itself actually has some problems that I fixed (such as a scale problem), but otherwise it's pretty stable. I have over 100 projects in my instance and it's working really well.
I used Rhodecode for awhile before they sold out - and while it was nice looking - it seemed like every new version introduced a new bug or issue. It was also a pain upgrading.
A lot of people dislike google code because it doesn't have the "social" aspects of pull requests - but the pull requests I've offered have not been pulled or the author of the project wanted to keep requesting modifications that it just wasn't worth my time. The later was actually an important fix because his project was just completely broken...
I like google code because it's just simple no frills. Uploads/wikis/source all right there.
I like GitLab more than Gitorious on a purely technical level, but GitLab unfortunately has a CLA[0] and uses the MIT expat license, whereas Gitorious used the AGPL.
I guess I will just self-host my own GitLab CE instance now.
[0] http://ebb.org/bkuhn/blog/2014/06/09/do-not-need-cla.html