But well, anyway we decide to call that beast, a VCS with distributed commits and centrilized (fetchable) history, with a simplified evolution graph (created by the point of view of a central server) would bring 99.99% of the benefit of a centralized VCS, 99.99% of the benefit of a DVCS, and almost no problems from any of them.
I'm sure that you could probably build the system that you are describing on top of git, but you would still run into problems with large files and local commits, even if it was just "commits since last pull/push."
The other part about the simplified evolution graph is completely missing. I don't think one can solve that without completely rewriting the protocol.
git currently can't do that because of the way it's designed and built.