Then again maybe I'm a bit psycho-rigid on build management :)
This tends to happen especially in shops that migrate off process-heavy monsters like clearcase and MKS. These tools do a lot more than just version control, and no open source version control system by itself matches what users of these systems expect. You have to throw at least an issue tracker and a good build tool into the mix as well.
Because of "we'll just add a submodule and we don't need a build system and it's only a single one and we'll replace that with a proper build tooling as soon as we have time". And then it's only a second one and suddenly submodules pop up like mushrooms after a light summer rain. It requires planning and forethought, just like a lot of things that should be an obvious huge benefit, but planning and forethought are in short supply in this industry.
git-annex is a pretty good solution for this: https://git-annex.branchable.com/
> That's a strawman. The article does not argue that there's no use-case that's solved by git or and DVCS. It's just that not every use-case is solved by git. I'd even go out and argue that most use-cases are solved just as good by a solid centralized system with less complexity involved.
I'm not convinced that it is a strawman– I'm not an uber-developer, but I've had to do it reasonably often. A common case is that the originator loses interest, and you still need to do maintenance on it. I'd rather my go-to choice of a version control system support that notion rather than learn a different tool to deal with this case.
> I see a developer wedge his git repo with a pull + rebase about once a month. And then somebody needs to walk over and explain. DVCS fundamentally introduce complexity that is not always needed. And I doubt that the fundamental complexity can be abstracted away.
Sure, there is an additional level of abstraction, but to argue that it's insurmountable seems rather pessimistic. Most technologies that we take for granted now required multiple decades to get to a consumer-friendly state. This is perhaps a philosophical difference that only time will answer.