News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Computing is too easy by 300bps on Tuesday March 03, 2015 @06:56AM (#9137213)
I agree with the article. The differences between 10 year old me on my Commodore 64 and my currently 10 year old son on his Windows 7 computer are astronomical. When I turned my 64 on it was "READY" for me to make it do something. I spent days typing in BASIC and 6502 Assembly source code into it just to play a game. My son has a seemingly infinite supply of videos on YouTube to entertain him. Near infinite supply of free-to-play ready made games (with in-app purchases). There is no natural incentive for him to learn how to produce anything on computers.
Re:Computing is too easy by baldfat on Tuesday March 03, 2015 @07:35AM (#9137331)
I also agree. Today we need people who can miss the forest for the trees! I can't believe the lack of basic computer skills that people have coming into the workforce and someone that can use Word is considered a computer person. Even the new IT people only know GUI and Microsoft with no experience with Mac OS or Linux, and no idea about anything but the silo they are working in.

I was one of those kids who had to program games at 7 on a Sol20 in 1977 and than de-bug since every basic was different. When I found out if I could learn Assembly I could play more game I learned that. The day I got the 300 baud modem was life changing and I had to pay for a second line due to everyone else in the house being mad they couldn't use the phone.

Re:Computing is too easy by sthreet on Tuesday March 03, 2015 @09:28AM (#9137759)
Time to complain about my school. Our "computer" classes consisted of learning to: type, format word, type in a spreadsheet, format powerpoint (in a way that I think powerpoint is unnecessary for), one week total of messing around in garage band, one week of typing out the exact lines of html, copying instructions for dreamweaver.

EDIT: And then we do 'job' stuff in that class. Including making resumes that include our ability to use basic microsoft/adobe programs. I could have learned to do that without a manual or internet before the class. I can learn way more with internet just messing around in photoshop/gimp every once in a while.

Re:Computing is too easy by baldfat on Tuesday March 03, 2015 @02:47PM (#9140149)
It is time to put the science back into Computer Science and have it in Middle School and High School. My school district computer classes are business classes and the teachers need business degrees.
Re:Computing is too easy by prof_hobart on Tuesday March 03, 2015 @07:36AM (#9137339)
There are many more distractions these days, but I'm not sure that it's as clear cut as you suggest.

It's really not that hard to get kids into some form of coding today. I've run a Scratch[1] club for 8-10 year olds at my daughter's school and every single one of the kids there loved it. By the end of the first hour, they were all producing some form of animation that they could control and all were desperate to come back for the following week.

Compare that with the steep learning curve of BASIC on an 80s 8-bit machine. It would take days to get anything more exciting than "Hello World!" out of it. Most of the people I know who had Spectrums (I'm British) as kids never went near programming. Their entire use of the command line was LOAD "".

[1] https://scratch.mit.edu/ - just in case anyone's never seen it.

Re:Computing is too easy by sthreet on Tuesday March 03, 2015 @09:24AM (#9137738)
In my personal opinion everyone should learn the basics of programming for the same reason everyone claims that everyone needs four years of English classes and science classes and history classes, because it helps you look at the world in a different way. In addition, I personally have found that if I try to make a program to do math for me, I understand the math way better.

So thank you for teaching some people, because learning is fairly hard, though if you have a good teacher it doesn't seem like it would be as hard to me.

What is Spectrums though?

Re:Computing is too easy by prof_hobart on Tuesday March 03, 2015 @05:31PM (#9141254)
Spectrums is plural of Spectrum, as in Sinclair ZX Spectrum, the computer that 90% of British kids had in the 80s (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ZX_Spectrum).
Re:Computing is too easy by 300bps on Tuesday March 03, 2015 @08:24AM (#9137494)
Your point is solid, but your experience with Scratch is different than mine. My 10 year old son had very little interest in Scratch. I'm not entirely sure of the reason for this but I think it is related to:

1) It was hard to distribute his creations

2) Lack of natural aptitude / ability

3) Too easy to consume without producing

We had a little more success with Construct 2. The main difference being that the games could be distributed to an iPad or any other HTML 5 web browser effortlessly. Maybe Scratch addressed that already in the 18 months since we've used it?

Re:Computing is too easy by prof_hobart on Tuesday March 03, 2015 @05:59PM (#9141378)
You can easily distribute Scratch apps via their web site, but it's not really designed as a language to build full iPad apps etc. Its main purpose is to make learning the basics (control blocks, variables etc) easy and fun. By the time you're anywhere near something that you can distribute, you would have had to learn most of those basics. If something else, like Construct 2, works for you that's great.

I obviously don't know your kid, but I doubt that aptitude/ability is going to be a blocker from getting simple Scratch programs running. I know several others who've run classes to a wide range of ages and abilities and not one of the kids has failed to get to grips with the basics.

I can accept that attitude/interest (wanting to consume rather than produce) is going to be an issue for some children, but that's always been the case. And no matter how easy or hard it is to make things, those children aren't going to want to program.

My point was less about Scratch specifically - there's a few similarish programs out there that can be used instead. It's more that the incentive to learn and availability of distractions hasn't really changed in the 30 years since I was a kid, and if anything the barriers to getting into some form of programming have dropped drastically since those days.

Re:Computing is too easy by klez on Tuesday March 03, 2015 @08:51AM (#9137596)
May I suggest that you're starting from the premise that your kid is willing/able to learn programming and that programming is for everyone?

As your parent suggested, not everyone who had computers back than had or felt the need to program them.

Re:Computing is too easy by scoggs on Tuesday March 03, 2015 @09:50AM (#9137872)
Right. I think the next step would be to try and find a programming exercise that his son could make his own. Something that would self motivate him to solve a problem. I think this is one of the hardest parts of diving into any high level thinking skill or hobby: finding the motivation to take the first step on a years long journey.
Re:Computing is too easy by 300bps on Tuesday March 03, 2015 @12:09PM (#9138855)
May I suggest that you're starting from the premise that your kid is willing/able to learn programming

That is precisely why I put #2 in my list.

Re:Computing is too easy by donatj on Tuesday March 03, 2015 @09:04AM (#9137645)
I think about this a lot, there are a lot of distractions now days but when I am actually being productive I'm working on distractions for others. Sometimes I wonder if that's all computers are is a massive distraction?