Re:Why is e^(pi i) = -1?
by amalcon on Saturday October 31, 2009 @01:22AM
(#913297)
All of those (except the circle) have the 1/2 because they're integrals of something linear. While it's true that area and integral are closely related (the latter being a special case of the former), a circle is clearly not linear.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Why is e^(pi i) = -1?
by johnaspden on Saturday October 31, 2009 @08:52AM
(#913496)
As a circle expands, its area grows proportional to its circumference. The circumference is proportional to the radius.
So you're getting the area by integrating a linear thing.
As a circle expands, its area grows proportional to its circumference. The circumference is proportional to the radius.
Exactly. In symbols, this reads dA/dr = C ∝ r. Setting τ = C/r = 6.2831853…, we have dA = C dr = τ r dr => A = ½ τ r². Q.E.D.
johnaspden has it right. To put it more explicitly, we can calculate the area of a circle by integrating the differential element of area dA for an infinitesimal annulus from 0 to r. Now, dA is simply the arclength (circumference C) times the thickness dr; since the circumference scales linearly with radius, this leads to the integral of a linear function as follows:
dA = C dr = τ r dr => A = ½ τ r².