If you'd been investing let's say starting 2000 in a 401k, you put in money at regular intervals. So you were buying the whole way down and up.
You wouldn't simply have "held" a NASDAQ ETF.
However, when evaluating a course of action, I think looking at the upper and lower bounds of possible outcomes is a very wise thing to do, so in that sense it's relevant...
There are many stratagies where you would have gotten significant returns over that time period. EX: If you held say 50% nasdaq and 50% cash and then rebalanced your portfolio you would have been well ahead of the curve.
When it comes to investments, boring is a feature.
Not if you buy at regular intervals. If you had, say, $10K in a Nasdaq ETF in 2000, and invested the same amount at regular intervals between then and now, you'd have a 95% profit by now.
This is one of the reasons, and there are many more. If you held a Nasdaq ETF from 2000 until now, you would have had to wait to 15 years to make back most of your gains. The Nikkei has been even worse... http://www.bloomberg.com/quote/NKY:IND
That doesn't mean everyone should try to add alternative investments, I think most people should hold ETF's. But rather most people should not blindly follow the dogma of holding an ETF that represents the market regardless of market conditions.
I can't believe I'm going to recommend a Tony Robbins book, but his latest book on investing is actually pretty good, actually you just need to read chapters 5 and 6 to save you some time.
I'd recommend most people check out his "All Seasons" portfolio that he got from Ray Dalio. I mean if you can get Ray Dalio's expertise working for you, you've got a great chance of having things work out for you!
https://www.pwlcapital.com/en/Advisor/Ottawa/Cameron-Passmor...
EDIT Wow, based on the downvotes this struck a nerve. I don't think I said anything wrong here, do people just not want a balanced view?