Re:CompCert: A formally verified optimizing C compiler
by jerf on Monday March 02, 2015 @10:42AM
(#9132304)
Unless you implement the proved compiler from scratch yourself, no.
If you're not doing massive amounts of implementation yourself, you have not escaped from Ken Thompson's hack. All this does is rephrase how they promise to not hack you... it doesn't change the fact that what they say they do and what they actually do have nothing in particular connecting them.
I wouldn't worry about it until strong AI comes along though. Humans are barely capable of making compilers that work, let alone shipping compromised compilers. (I know Ken demonstrated his hack, but to make something that does that under controlled conditions is one thing, to make one that could be shipped and robustly implement the hack quite another.)
If you're not doing massive amounts of implementation yourself, you have not escaped from Ken Thompson's hack. All this does is rephrase how they promise to not hack you... it doesn't change the fact that what they say they do and what they actually do have nothing in particular connecting them.
I wouldn't worry about it until strong AI comes along though. Humans are barely capable of making compilers that work, let alone shipping compromised compilers. (I know Ken demonstrated his hack, but to make something that does that under controlled conditions is one thing, to make one that could be shipped and robustly implement the hack quite another.)