Re:How We Learned to Kill
by TeMPOraL on Sunday March 01, 2015 @07:37PM
(#9129653)
> From a utilitarian standpoint, all you look at are the possible actions and the possible results. From a moral standpoint, actively killing someone is much worse than letting someone get killed.
I disagree. What the trolley problem shows is that it's better to save many lives than just one, thus most people decide to pull the lever. As for why in real world you don't go and kill people for the greater good, is that our brains run on a corrupted hardware. "The end justifies the means" is a valid line of reasoning, but not for humans - because we predictably end up doing more bad than good when we follow it.
> Would you be willing to let everything and everyone you love perish?
If you put it that way, then killing one person to avoid this outcome is just like pulling the lever in the trolley problem.
>> I would shoot only if shot upon, not because its moral, but because I'd feel like a coward idiot to do otherwise.
This is a complex topic. I bet GP would shoot back when shot upon just because survival instinct kicks in. But barring that, social pressure is indeed a strong factor. I recall stories of Jehovah's Witnesses (die-hard pacifists) who got conscripted during First World War, back before the movement developed the idea that going to prison for your beliefs is a Right Thing; those soldiers would keep intentionally missing when shooting, in order to follow the "do not kill" commandement while avoiding getting imprisoned/executed for refusing to fight.
I disagree. What the trolley problem shows is that it's better to save many lives than just one, thus most people decide to pull the lever. As for why in real world you don't go and kill people for the greater good, is that our brains run on a corrupted hardware. "The end justifies the means" is a valid line of reasoning, but not for humans - because we predictably end up doing more bad than good when we follow it.
Here's a good analysis of the topic: http://lesswrong.com/lw/uv/ends_dont_justify_means_among_hum....
> Would you be willing to let everything and everyone you love perish?
If you put it that way, then killing one person to avoid this outcome is just like pulling the lever in the trolley problem.
>> I would shoot only if shot upon, not because its moral, but because I'd feel like a coward idiot to do otherwise.
This is a complex topic. I bet GP would shoot back when shot upon just because survival instinct kicks in. But barring that, social pressure is indeed a strong factor. I recall stories of Jehovah's Witnesses (die-hard pacifists) who got conscripted during First World War, back before the movement developed the idea that going to prison for your beliefs is a Right Thing; those soldiers would keep intentionally missing when shooting, in order to follow the "do not kill" commandement while avoiding getting imprisoned/executed for refusing to fight.