Did you realise how that phrase is incredibly dangerously close to this other one:
"You can't blame a Government for preventively imprison or kill someone because some of its bureaucrat has perceived threat" ?
You bliss the first one and you have nothing left to contain the other one from happening
Unless you are a believer of the capability to self-refrain of an ever expanding Government.
It's not. Because soldiers are thrown into battle and forced to make snap decisions that determine whether they'll live or die the very next second, while the Government has both more time for deliberation and much, much wider range of possible actions to take.
> You bliss the first one and you have nothing left to contain the other one from happening
This does not follow. My point was - if they're shooting at you and you're not allowed to run, what can you do except shoot back? The problem is with those who put you in a position where you're getting shot at.
> Unless you are a believer of the capability to self-refrain of an ever expanding Government.
Of course I don't. I just feel that focusing on front-line soldiers is the wrong place to start solving this problem.
You'd have to enact a global and immediate mentality change to beat the coordination problem inherent in this situation.
Dying defending your freedom is something very very different to justifying others people killing based on assumptions of threat after a preemptive war of aggression [2]
The only thing that can try to keep such an illusion consistent is Exceptionalism [3] which would magically give you self-serving moral superpowers.
Extrapolate that a little bit and you will see how Exceptionalism escalates to some form Elitist Dystopia [4]
[1] - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conscientious_objector [2] - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_of_aggression [3] - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exceptionalism [4] - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dystopia
I'm not defending the atrocities many a soldier committed on purpose. There are many unforgivable things that happen during war. But in the current shape of warfare, you can't blame soldiers for using lethal force against a perceived lethal threat. Let's develop phasers with stun settings that are as effective as guns, and then we can go back to this conversation.
EDIT: Come on. Off-topic or not, you're breaking the conversation flow by deleting your responses. Those comments are useful for context even if some of us disagree with them.