News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday March 01, 2015 @12:16PM (#9127885)
> Do they use those protected profits to build a network which they then sell to consumers?

I don't understand this argument at all. Having access to capital isn't an "unfair advantage" -- it's a hard prerequisite to building a network. Nobody can do it without that.

And sources of money are never unfair. If somebody has easier access to capital than you, that isn't an "unfair" advantage, it's a completely reasonable advantage. It isn't unreasonable for large entities to invest in things they want to just because they have more money than you.

The only way it would be unfair is if they were operating below cost in the long term, which has nothing to do with where they get the money and which they aren't doing and have no reason to do.

Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by jusben1369 on Sunday March 01, 2015 @02:58PM (#9128619)
Hmmm. Let's say people in your state love bananas and the average price of a banana is $1 with a profit of 20 cents. And your friend who is married to the daughter of the governor suddenly has an exclusive license to sell bananas in your state. What do you think will happen to the price of bananas and subsequently what do you think happens to profits your friend starts accruing? Ok, so far so good you don't really care because you don't like bananas. You are your 10 friends sell apples and you all compete hard against each other and sell an Apple for between 95 cents and $1.05 cents. One day your friend thinks the Apple business looks interesting. He's raised the price of bananas to $1.20 and is now making 40 cents a banana. Now he starts selling Apples. At 70 cents each. 10 cents below cost. He's losing 10 cents on every apple but he doesn't care because he makes 40 cents on every banana he's selling. Naturally in 9 months you and your 10 friends are out of business. You can't sell Apples at a loss. Once you leave he raises the price of Apples to $1.10. Feel tempted to jump back in? No way, he'll just drop them to 70 cents each for a while and crush you a second time.

All of this happens because your friend has an unfair advantage in terms of his access to capital. Power utilities (and cable and internet too) are great examples of law mandated monopolies who generate protected profits. Taking that protected revenue stream to subsidize your entrance into a competitive marketplace isn't fair.

Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by AnthonyMouse on Monday March 02, 2015 @06:06PM (#9134996)
You're talking about antitrust, which is ugly and complicated, and you're making several mistakes.

But this is the fundamental one:

> All of this happens because your friend has an unfair advantage in terms of his access to capital.

It really has nothing to do with that at all. A dollar is a dollar. If it takes a billion dollars to sell below cost for long enough that all your competitors to leave the market permanently, it doesn't make any difference where you got the money.

Which is why the thing you're describing is illegal regardless of the source of the money. The banana monopolist is not allowed to do it and neither is Warren Buffet or Bank of America or anybody else.

Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by gonzo on Sunday March 01, 2015 @03:43PM (#9128795)
As if VZW didn't have access to cheap money. RBABs, anyone?
Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by jusben1369 on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:20AM (#9131683)
Yes but cheap money is very different to protected money.