Re:Most trading strategies are not tested rigorously enough
by consz on Sunday March 01, 2015 @11:33AM
(#9127676)
Agreed, errors are non-normal so 20+ sigma is practically false. But it's not too far off -- I've seen strategies that never have a down day and have daily sharpes of 2.5-3.0, and those setups will generally have incredibly high sigma values even after accounting for non-normality (and other assumptions).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Most trading strategies are not tested rigorously enough
by joosters on Sunday March 01, 2015 @11:42AM
(#9127714)
Remember, strategies that 'never have a down day' are only one day away from having a down day...
...and there are plenty of strategies that had only a single down day, unfortunately that one down day wiping out the entire company :)
Re:Most trading strategies are not tested rigorously enough
by consz on Sunday March 01, 2015 @11:54AM
(#9127771)
Sure, but most strategies have such small positions that even if the market went to 0 instantly at your maximum long position, you'd still lose less than a year's worth of PNL in that strategy. The more relevant risk of blowout is something like Knight happening, statistical black swan events are not really an issue (in HFT).
Re:Most trading strategies are not tested rigorously enough
by stevewepay on Sunday March 01, 2015 @11:38PM
(#9130357)
I used to be very big into algorithmic and day trading, and one trader I was introduced to had Martingale'd himself into a record of something like 2 years without suffering a loss. Then he suffered a 300k loss and wiped out all of his earning plus more and then he lost a lot of his followers, at least for a while.