But that's nonsense. If anything a sovereign digital currency would give governments even more fine-grained control over the money supply.
Of course governments shouldn't use Bitcoin, but a sovereign altcoin is a very interesting idea.
Sure, they couldn't use Bitcoin itself, but in a hypothetical world of government-backed cryptocurrencies Bitcoin would be more of a reserve commodity, like gold, than a circulating fiat currency.
A sovereign cryptocurrency without that limitation might be an interesting alternative to cash, but the bulk of our money couldn't be in a "hard" cryptocurrency unless we also eliminated fractional reserve banking.
(Why? In short, with fractional reserve banking, the total value of everyones checking and savings accounts is far greater than the supply of currency, whether paper or crypto.)
But the real hallmark of FRB is that banks only need hold in reserve a fraction of their depositors' account balances. I don't see how CC would change that requirement. As scary as FRB is, without it lending would be a much, much more limited activity.
Money is funny - it's just an IOU. An IOU blown up to massive scale, obviously, but since a business sets the price of something and the market determines if it fits well in to a tradable value comparison, then I don't see how a digital IOU is any worse than a paper one, considering how little that paper is worth when everyone decides it has no value.
And let's be honest. If the value of paper can crash when people agree it has no value, it's just as easy for everyone to agree gold isn't worth a lick either. So in the end, we're just choosing a representation of an IOU we all agree upon, and if that's paper, rock, or digital (or 4 ton coins [0]) what does it matter, in the end?
(This all presumes some degree of safety in CC - with the recent value of Bitcoin thefts, people would ditch it really quickly on a national scale.)
/rambling
> But the real hallmark of FRB is that banks only need hold in reserve a fraction of their depositors' account balances. I don't see how CC would change that requirement.
My question is, what will a CC replace? If the answer is all cash and electronic transactions, will there be enough CC, with FRB? If the answer is simply cash transactions (already limited), what's the point?
In fact, you could probably utilize the increase in the money supply in much more productive ways than the current system, which primarily benefits banking institutions.
what if Keynes is wrong?
But a purely digital currency need not be a distributed cryptocurrency with a limited supply like Bitcoin.
From electronic transactions with the Fed down to direct deposits and debit and credit card purchases, US currency could function without paper bills already.