Re:The Case for D
by Keyframe on Friday October 30, 2009 @10:50AM
(#912093)
D1 + Tango == yes! Excellent combo, but serious lack in the toolchain department. DMD and OPTLINK especially is a failboat currently. LDC is based on LLVM and is "the future", but lacks windows support (exceptions! and this is inherently LLVM's problem now). DDBG is a good debugger, but is unmaintained. GDC is D on GCC, but is unmaintained.
D2 on the other hand doesn't feel like D anymore at all. Sure, there are a couple of nice things in it like ranges, but on the general perspective I could make this comparison: D1 is like C with C++ made right. D2 is D++, what C++ is to C - bloat and inconsistency.
There is also a huuuge problem with D2 and leadership/drama, which split the community. There is also problem with Phobos vs Tango - where Tango is clearly and measurably better, but that thread of issues leads to leadership drama.
Let me be clear on this (I use D every day for my projects - I am into graphics/gamedev with it). Do yourself a favor and learn D1/Tango - toolchain is bearable and there is a book about it from Apress. Community is responsive (#d, #d.tango on freenode if you demand prompt resolutions). Use Tango from SVN, use LDC or DMD if you are on Windows.
There are some movements within the community that will resolve by themselves soon enough - it's too good to fall apart. In the mean time you should really do yourself a favor and give it a go.
D2 on the other hand doesn't feel like D anymore at all. Sure, there are a couple of nice things in it like ranges, but on the general perspective I could make this comparison: D1 is like C with C++ made right. D2 is D++, what C++ is to C - bloat and inconsistency.
There is also a huuuge problem with D2 and leadership/drama, which split the community. There is also problem with Phobos vs Tango - where Tango is clearly and measurably better, but that thread of issues leads to leadership drama.
Let me be clear on this (I use D every day for my projects - I am into graphics/gamedev with it). Do yourself a favor and learn D1/Tango - toolchain is bearable and there is a book about it from Apress. Community is responsive (#d, #d.tango on freenode if you demand prompt resolutions). Use Tango from SVN, use LDC or DMD if you are on Windows.
Also, check out http://www.team0xf.com:1024 - especially dog (OpenGL platform agnostic binding) and hybrid (gui on top of it). Check out http://www.dsource.org .
There are some movements within the community that will resolve by themselves soon enough - it's too good to fall apart. In the mean time you should really do yourself a favor and give it a go.