BT Openreach is the successor to the government monopoly that built the phone lines, and still owns them. As a condition of privatization, they are required to lease the lines to competitors, but, and this is key, the prices for such leases are set using a "price cap" system which ensures they have an incentive to keep investing in the network: http://siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTFINANCIALSECTOR/Resour.... In practice, the price caps are set high enough that Openreach makes a lot of money. If you dig into the financials, they make way more than ATT and Verizon make on their wired networks, and about as much as they make on their wireless networks.
So no, it's not just "forced line sharing." It's about putting publicly-built infrastructure into a company that's insulated from competition, and regulating their prices in a way that ensures they are very profitable.
> Why do you dismiss the anti-NN concerns as FUD?
He said anti-NN were spreading a lot of FUD. I didn't see him say all anti-NN concerns were FUD.
And he's right about a lot of FUD from anti-NN people. Some claims I saw, largely from Republican official, Republican writers and radio/TV hosts, and random people whose affiliation was not stated but from their remarks about Obama being a communist, dirty liberal, or Muslim I think it is a safe bet that they are not moderates or liberals:
• You will have to apply for an expensive license from the FCC if you want to put up a website.
• The FCC will be regulating Google search results, Facebook's news feed, and the like.
• This helps the governments of North Korea, Syria, Iran, and China to oppress their people with their internet censorship, because now the US cannot pressure them for a free internet without appearing hypocritical because now we are imposing the same kind of controls on the internet in the US.
> What incentive will telecom companies have to build the wireline networks that enable next-generation of web services if they can't make enough money to justify the investment?
What money making opportunity, besides paid prioritization, does this remove?
> The fact that these points are also raised by the telecom companies [...]
By some telecom companies. T-Mobile and Sprint aren't having much of a problem with it. The rural broadband provider's trade group outright supports it and has long asked for Title II.
> I'm not an ideologue. I'd be fine with, for example, the U.K. approach. But what that would mean, which most people on HN don't know, would be putting AT&T back together and letting them enjoy monopoly profits.
What do you mean by the U.K. approach? The main aspect of their broadband approach that I'm aware of us the forced line sharing, but I don't see how that would require putting AT&T back together.
Question: wireless voice has been regulated under similar (but more extensive) Title II regulations for around 20 years. Why have the doom and gloom scenarios forecast for internet not already come to pass there? The carriers there have invested massively in their infrastructure under those rules.