But I've been wondering, does voting third party work better than voting for good else greater evil? Voting third party means in most races your desires can be ignored, as you won't be voting for either candidate likely to win and thus will have no impact on the election. But if you vote for good else greater evil, in a system where most are either voting party regardless of actual candidate are voting for the lesser evil, do you have a better chance of getting the lesser evil side to try to change policies enough they register as good?
If you are lucky enough to live somewhere where third party has a chance, that is the best choice. But what is the optimal strategy for those of us who don't?
Longer-term, we can push for range or approval voting, which don't penalize you for voting your true preference. They're legal under current law and compatible with voting machines. We could start small: third-party primaries, local elections, etc.
If you vote for the candidate that lost but still had 40% of the vote (and polls showed that ahead of time), does that mean your vote had no impact? Is your vote only meaningful if you vote for the candidate that won? If not, where is this (subjective?) line?
> If you are lucky enough to live somewhere where third party has a chance, that is the best choice. But what is the optimal strategy for those of us who don't?
The optimal strategy is to be the third option. It's how the system is supposed to work.