Re:Ask HN: Is it safe to use Facebook's open source projects?
by Denvercoder9 on Thursday February 26, 2015 @08:40AM
(#9112395)
> What if I merely live in the EU and thus implicitly agree to the laws in Europw. Does that fall under "other action" or would I have to explicitly state that I think their patents are not enforceable.
It doesn't matter. If their patents aren't valid where you live, you don't need their patent grant.
Re:Ask HN: Is it safe to use Facebook's open source projects?
by kriro on Thursday February 26, 2015 @08:54AM
(#9112459)
If I live where I do and thus could be said to agree with the fact that their patents cannot be enforced here it still matters if I want to use it for software that is used elsewhere.
The way I read it I could be constructed as claiming their patents are not enforcable here and thus the grant would be revoked in countries where I'd need it (not here).
What if I merely live in the EU and thus implicitly agree to the laws in Europw. Does that fall under "other action" or would I have to explicitly state that I think their patents are not enforceable.
What if I have actively participated in the anti software patents movement? Do I have to single out specific Facebook patents for this clause to trigger or is it enough that they are caught in the general umbrella?
Edit: I'm assuming this is found on all the stuff they release and not just fbcunn? At least it's also true for react: https://github.com/facebook/react/blob/master/PATENTS