News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An Outspoken Voice for Women in Tech, Foiled by His Tone by smacktoward on Wednesday February 25, 2015 @04:24PM (#9109721)
I don't see how it's that hard to avoid Wadhwa's mistake. Despite what the article asserts, from what I've seen his problem wasn't so much his tone on Twitter as it was that he was putting himself forward -- and being booked to speak at conferences, etc. -- as a spokesperson for women in tech. And the spokesperson for women in tech shouldn't be a man, no matter how well-intentioned he is. It should be a woman. Women are perfectly capable of speaking for themselves; they don't need a man to do it for them.

If you're a man (like I am!), and you want to help women in tech (like I do!), and someone approaches you to speak at a conference about that, the thing to do is to recommend some awesome women you know to speak instead. Instead of talking about how women need support in this industry, support an actual woman in the industry.

Otherwise you run the risk of coming off like Wadhwa did. He looked like a carpetbagger (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carpetbagger) -- someone who had identified a hot trend and jumped on it to raise his own personal profile. And if you're a man who sincerely wants to help women, the way you do that is by helping them raise their own profiles, rather than using their problems to goose your own.

Re:An Outspoken Voice for Women in Tech, Foiled by His Tone by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday February 25, 2015 @04:55PM (#9109967)
Yet, that's cutting out half the available supporters of equal rights, isn't it? Only women may speak about women's issues, seems reasonable. Until you have something to say, and others aren't saying it. Then what? Do you choose a puppet to speak for you? Do you keep silent, hoping someone will make your point for you? What about venues where there ARE no women?
Re:An Outspoken Voice for Women in Tech, Foiled by His Tone by Lawtonfogle on Wednesday February 25, 2015 @05:02PM (#9110031)
You also now open a problem where women should not be speaking for men. Do we really want to enforce such a gendered nature onto our public discourse?
Re:An Outspoken Voice for Women in Tech, Foiled by His Tone by lkbm on Wednesday February 25, 2015 @11:44PM (#9111227)
This is specifically public discouse about gender-specific issues.

Maybe it's okay for a man to be the spokesperson for women's issues, or a white person to be the spokesperson for black issues, but it's important to realize you're speaking for someone else. It's really hard to do that better than that someone. Maybe I'm a better public speaker. Maybe people are more likely to listen to me. Maybe I even have a better understanding of power dynamics and sociology and tech culture. But it's also really, really critical to have an understanding of the perspectives of those I'm speaking for. That's hard. And in this situation, seems like a bunch of those people seemed to feel that wasn't the case.

Re:An Outspoken Voice for Women in Tech, Foiled by His Tone by Lawtonfogle on Thursday February 26, 2015 @10:12AM (#9112862)
If I'm being given information about heart attacks, I'd much rather hear from a doctor who is well informed on the scientific consensus than a survivor of a heart attack, even if the doctor has never had a single heart problem. Why is information about the experiences of gender or race so different than all other information, being that for any other information, experience is neither necessary nor sufficient for expertise?

Also, anecdotal experience, even by large numbers of the population, should not be taken as anything significant without a scientific endeavor to interpret them. Consider the numerous parents who will state "As a parent..." when disagreeing with an expert on child development. Even if thousands of parents disagree, even if the expert has never been a parent, an immunologist saying children should receive vaccines is still correct.

In all other fields, the expert lacking personal experience has the better perspective than part of the population impacted with their own personal anecdotes.

Re:An Outspoken Voice for Women in Tech, Foiled by His Tone by dragonwriter on Wednesday February 25, 2015 @07:35PM (#9110704)
> And the spokesperson for women in tech shouldn't be a man

I think this would be more accurate with the "a man" part. The spokesperson for women in tech shouldn't be. Women in tech aren't a monolithic group such that a spokesperson is sufficient.

Re:An Outspoken Voice for Women in Tech, Foiled by His Tone by Lawtonfogle on Wednesday February 25, 2015 @05:01PM (#9110022)
>It should be a woman.

Why? You explanation shows why women are perfectly valid candidates; they don't need a man. But why would a man be a bad choice? Why do they need a woman?