News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:XKCD Explained, One Strip at a Time by Semiapies on Thursday October 29, 2009 @04:40PM (#910851)
"You see, you'd normally expect explanations of jokes to be funny."

Who would expect that? It's a old cliche that explaining a joke isn't funny or entertaining. I certainly wasn't expecting humor when I looked at it.

(Nor did I find any, but then, the "it's funny because it's not funny" shtick is right up there with "Bill Clinton is a horny guy, amirite?" jokes in Dated Gag Heaven.)

Re:XKCD Explained, One Strip at a Time by KirinDave on Thursday October 29, 2009 @05:10PM (#910933)
Well, there is an interesting effect. Some of the jokes in XKCD are so bad that explaining them dryly has the unintended consequence of making them funnier. For example, http://bit.ly/UiiM5.
Re:XKCD Explained, One Strip at a Time by Semiapies on Thursday October 29, 2009 @05:25PM (#910953)
Not really. It's just "unfunny" and "uninteresting description of unfunny".

Now, if there were an additional level of description, something could be salvaged.

"The writer of the explanation characterizes a 'full rugby uniform' as lacking any trousers, belt, or shoes to invoke homophobic stereotypes about the English."

...Meh, maybe not even that would help.