News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why digital natives prefer reading in print by anigbrowl on Tuesday February 24, 2015 @02:11PM (#9102783)
I find most e-formatted books to be terrible

Several people have brought this up, and I think it's a great example of path-dependency and bad choices. I remember when CDs first became available and enterprising publishers were trying to think of what to do with all that space, so they made 'shovelware' CDs containing hundreds of shareware games or other commodifiable stuff - particulary the 'Project Gutenberg' collections of classic books in electronic form. Great! But when you'd open them up, they were a mess of line breaks, chapter headings (on every page), page numbers. Even today, the default UTF-8 text versions are still formatted for 80 character terminals or the dot-matrix pritners that preceded them.

The basic literary units (regardless of topic) are words, sentences, and paragraphs. Not lines. Even the most humble text editor has an inbuilt word-wrapping capability; there is no reason to add line breaks to a digital text. 'But,' some will argue, 'what about people who are in a terminal and trying to read something using 'more'?' Well, use a damn pipe. It's insanely stupid to digitize a text and then impose device-specific formatting on it. If something needs to be highly organized in the manner of a technical book, then mark it up properly with TeX or whatever. But if it's linear and doesn't depend on specific typography, then there's no reason to be baking any formatting in.

There are no comments on this comment yet.