News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why digital natives prefer reading in print by anigbrowl on Tuesday February 24, 2015 @01:21PM (#9102452)
It's a loss of capability, and a loss of personal freedom and empowerment.

Wait, people's choice to prefer physical media is a loos of freedom and empowerment? That's a hard argument to make. It seems to me that you're arguing that the failure of others to share your consumption preferences means that there's insufficient market pressure to on suppliers to deliver content in a way that suits you.

I like the idea of e-books but in practice I loathe reading them. That's inconvenient, because we have a lot of books and I read fast, so moving house means dealing with several hundred pounds of printed matter and wrangling bookshelves. But the textural substrate of the physical book is far mroe appealing to me than any e-reader, not to mention being able to pencil notes on the margin or the creative pleasures of discovering epehemera of prior readers in used books, from personal ntoes to airline tickets. Likewise, DVD or blu-rays often deliver better viewing quality than streaming alternatives (although I use Netflix streaming regularly), and more importantly they often contain valuable extras - at least I find them valuable, because I work in film so things like interviews or director commentaries can have significant professional utility. Downside is having the wrangle the physical disks and annoying publisher lead-ins/piracy warnings and so on.

As for photos, I have thousands of digital ones as I shoot a lot, but ones I really like get printed and I also still shoot things on film because film grain color etc/ is so aesthetically pleasing. Film sets are generally digital these days, and that means shooting a bland, low-contrast image in order to maximize dynamic range and treat the footage with an appropriate 'look' in post. Economically this makes a great deal of sense and I love the possibilities it opens up, but I also enjoy shooting blind on junk cameras (even a hand cranked one) to see what I'll get. Digital is a great complement to working with or viewing physical media, but it need not and probably should not become a substitute. I have photos and artwork of mine hanging on the wall that I originated digitally, but I also enjoy brushes and paint; I do most of my writing at a keyboard but I carry notepaper and pencil everywhere because I enjoy writing things by hand, and because switching between different media is often a good way to escape creative blockages.

There are no comments on this comment yet.